What people say about us -

THE TELEGRAPH WRITES

Voicing the whispers
Suresh Mehrotra is focused on bringing what goes on inside the country’s corridors of power to the world outside, says Smita Tripathi
FACE OF THE WEEK - Suresh Mehrotra

Three guesses as to what most IAS officers do on reaching office every morning? Order a cup of tea? Bury their noses in a newspaper? Heck, maybe even do some work and ask for the list of appointments for the day?

Oh no, they crank up their computers and log on to www.whispersinthecorridors. com, a website, which has taken the country’s bureaucracy by storm. Who is going to be the next cabinet secretary? Who has moved up the ladder? Who has been kicked off it? Have transfer orders been issued? And who is returning to their cadre? Basically just about all the inner goings on in the corridors of power find its way to this website.

So who’s the mole spilling all the bureaucratic beans? Some speculate that he must be a bureaucrat while others suspect he’s a low-level functionary in the personnel ministry. But they are all wrong. Meet Suresh Mehrotra, a doctorate in history and a journalist by profession who runs the whispersinthe corridors website from a small room in his house in Bhopal — with just one computer. Mehrotra has informers in every department and even senior bureaucrats leak to him. But ask him to reveal their names and he’ll grin and repeat the old mantra: “A journalist never reveals his sources.”

No surprises there! In fact, Mehrotra’s sources are placed so deep within the system that hardly any information on the country’s “Iron Frame” passes him by. Consider this: a few months ago Mehrotra got a call at the crack of dawn with earthshaking — from a bureaucratic point of view — news. The cabinet secretary had been given a two-year extension.

Mehrotra uploaded the information on his website immediately. It was only later in the evening that the government announced the decision and it became the top story on every news channel. However, by this time most bureaucrats across the country were hotly debating the last minute change, thanks to Mehrotra’s website.

Says Mehrotra, “People expect me to know everything. I have senior IAS officers calling me to check whether their name is on a particular list or not.” It goes without saying that he doesn’t mind the attention. In fact he basks in it. “People often refer to me as Mr India (referring to Anil Kapoor’s role in a film of the same name), since I’m only heard and not seen,” he laughs.

Whispersin thecorridor.com started humbly enough in March 2001, with an initial investment of around Rs 50,000. It received only two hits on Day One. Today, it has more than 2.6 million visitors and is read both by bureaucrats in India, and also those attached to Indian embassies abroad. In fact, the site enjoys such credibility that bureaucrats often quote it.

Mehrotra has an anecdote about a senior officer who was hoping to be transferred to a new department. Whispersinthecorridor carried an item that he was about to be transferred, so the officer went to his boss asking to be relieved of his job. His ingenious argument? — ‘if the website said it, it must be true’. He got his orders the very next day.

Says Mehrotra, “Sometimes I know things before the officers themselves.” He goes on to talk about a secretary level officer who the website said was going to be moved to a different ministry. The officer’s son-in-law called him up from the US to ask if it was true. The officer, not a regular visitor of the whispersinthecorridor site, had no clue but two days later, he was moved.

Just how does Mehrotra get all this sensitive information? “It’s a give-and-take relationship. Some information I part with, and some they give me,” he says referring to his bureaucrat buddies. On an average, Mehrotra sends out between 25 to 30 mails a day and makes around 50 calls to various people sitting not only in Delhi but also in other state secretariats.

And how did it all start? “It was my fascination with the bureaucracy and the way the government worked. I was never much interested in the political side of things. It was the bureaucrats who attracted me,” says Mehrotra.

So in the mid-1980’s, Mehrotra, then the bureau chief of the Free Press Journal in Bhopal started a weekly column called Whispers in the Corridors. Of course, the column only covered the activities of the officers of the Madhya Pradesh government. “It was a huge success and I realised that there were a lot of people who were interested in knowing what was happening at the seat of power,” he explains.

In 1992, Mehrotra moved to Delhi for a year. “I spent most of my time in Delhi meeting bureaucrats. Today most of them are my close friends,” he says. From 1997 to 2000, Mehrotra was the editor of National Mail and then went on to edit the Hindi daily, Nayee Duniya.

However at these organisations, he didn’t get much chance to pursue his passion for the bureaucracy. So in 2001, he set up the website. “I thought it was time for me to do something on my own. The website was just an idea,” says Mehrotra who initially had to face a lot of flak from his bureaucrat friends when he called them up asking for information to put on his site.

Cut to the present and it’s an entirely different story. “Now people often call me up and give me information, even without my asking for it. In fact, sometimes they try to plant stories about others. I need to be cautious and crosscheck such information with my sources,” says Mehrotra who as a rule tries to stay away from controversies. “I concentrate only on the comings and goings rather than on issues of corruption. Investigative journalism is for newspapers. I only give information,” he declares.

Running the website costs Mehrotra around Rs 50,000 a month thanks to the server fees and the telephone bills. He has also recruited one person who uploads the site daily at around 11 am. Apart from that, it’s a completely home-run operation.

For the first couple of years Mehrotra wasn’t making any money, but now he says he is breaking even. The site gets advertisements from the Madhya Pradesh and Chattisgarh governments. “Most advertising is through contacts. I don’t undertake any marketing,” he says. But now, more and more people are approaching him for advertising. Recently the IAS Wives Association has started advertising on the website for a new housing complex that they are building.

So what’s the future like for whispersinthecorridors. com? Like all dot.com entrepreneurs, Mehrotra hopes that some day the site will be big enough for a company to make him an offer he just can’t refuse. Till then, Mehrotra continues to do what he loves — give voice to all those whispers floating around in the corridors of power.

Photograph by Jagan Negi

Justice Arun Kumar to be Chairman of TDSAT

Former Judge of the Supreme Court of India, Justice Arun Kumar, is all set to take over as new Chairman of the TDSAT in a week or two.

PM clears 1976 empanelment file

Prime Minister Manmohan Singh has cleared the empanelment file of 1976 batch IAS officers to the rank of Additional Secretary.

Lambor Rynjah moves to Planning Commission

Additional Secretary in the Ministry of Rural Development, Lambor Rynjah, has been moved to the Planning Commission. He is 1974 batch IAS officer of Assam-Meghalaya cadre.

Will Peter Mukherjee be CEO of Prasar Bharti ?

CEO of the Star Operations in India, Peter Mukherjee, is being persuaded by Union Information and Broadcasting Minister Priya Ranjan Das Munshi to join as CEO of the Prasar Bharti. Will Mukherjee agree ?

Chaitanya Kalbag to be Editor-in-Chief of HT

Veteran Journalist Chaitanya Kalbag is all set to take over as Editor-in-Chief of the Hindustan Times.

MP e-initiative against Blackmarketing

In a unique exercise in transparency, allocations to all the two lakh plus fair price shops are now on the website of the Department of Food, Civil Supplies and Consumer Affairs of the Government of Madhya Pradesh. Recently, the Central Government has recognized MP's " monitoring through videoconferencing as a ˜best practice "and recommended it to all states. These two initiatives, among others, are a part of "Zero Tolerance on Blackmarketing " drive by the State. Last year, two national surveys had found diversions and leakages in MP amongst the highest in India. Anand Asthana is the Principal Secretary Food and Civil Supplies.

Avay Shukla not joining GoI

Avay Shukla is not joining the Government of India . Name of 1975 batch Himachal Pradesh cadre IAS officer, Shukla, had been in circulation for the post of AS and FA in the Ministry of Rural Development.

Proposal of Atul Chaturvedi turned down

The PMO reportedly turned down the proposal of Atul Chaturvedi for the post of Additional Secretary and FA in the Ministry of Commerce. A proposal had been mooted to move 1974 batch UP cadre IAS officer, Chaturvedi, to the Commerce Ministry from the RD Ministry.

Arya to get promotion

Om Prakash Arya is getting in-situ promotion to the rank of Additional Secretary in the Government of India.1975 batch Uttaranchal cadre IAS officer, Arya, is presently Director Serious Fraud Investigation in the Ministry of Company Affairs.

Sikri to join Inter-State Council

D K Sikri is likely to be posted in the Inter-State Council in the rank of Additional Secretary. He is 1975 batch IAS officer of Gujarat cadre.

Will Seth be posted in Agriculture Ministry ?

Dr S P Seth is likely to be posted as Additional Secretary Agriculture in the Government of India. He is 1975 batch IAS officer of Bihar cadre.

Neelam Nath to get promotion

Ms Neelam Nath is likely to be promoted in the Planning Commission to the rank of Additional Secretary in the Government of India. She is 1975 batch IAS officer of Jharkhand cadre.

Agrawal unlikely to join

P K Agrawal unlikely to join the Government of India as Additional Secretary Agriculture. He is 1975 batch IAS officer of Andhra Pradesh cadre.

Maini was to move Planning Commission ?

There was original proposal to shift Additional Secretary Petro-Chemicals 1974 batch Punjab cadre IAS officer, Dr J S Maini, to the Planning Commission. The move, however, could not materialise.

Asha Swarup was to move Petro-Chemicals

Infact there was a proposal to shift Asha Swarup, AS and FA Commerce, to Petro-Chemicals in place of J S Maini. The proposal however did not find support in the PMO.

Uday Sahay to return to Delhi Police

DDG and CVO of Prasar Bharti, Uday Sahay, is returning to the parent UT cadre after completion of central deputation tenure.1988 batch IPS officer, Sahay, is handing over charge today.

Dakshina and partnership in Rajasthan galore

Rajasthan, the land of deserts, has these days come to be known as the land of Dakshina and Partnership. What does this signifies?

IPS changes in Madhya Pradesh

R L Borna has been appointed DIG APTC, Indore. R S Saket SP Narsinghpur will move to PHQ.B K Srivastava will be new SP of Narsinghpur.V K Suryavanshi has been posted as SP Raisen. J S Sanswal will join SAF.

IAS changes in Chhattisgarh

Ajay Singh has been appointed Excise Commissioner.C K Khaitan has been given additional charge of Secretary Urban Development.Jawahar Srivastava has also been given additional charge of Child and Women Welfare.

FORUM

I would not be so harsh if I am to judge bureaucrats. They are quite briliant and hardworking when recruited. But their service conditions which keeps giving them higher pay scales and put them on top without having to produce measurable and meaningful outputs spoils them. Such system would spoil anyone. Most bureaucrats get verygood or outstanding annual rating on their performance, but country continues to perform dismally. Problem is with evaluation and promotion system in govt. Lack of accountability is main issue. It promotes inefficiency and corruption. People at top do topmost damage in such system.
Juhi

Aaj Ki Aawaz

By the wonder of imagination I'm giving you an insight to what transpired in the Meeting between Sonia and Manmohan to decide who should become MEA.

Venue: 10 Janpath Library

Sonia: Namaste Manmohan ji …. how are you???
Manmohan: Namaste….. kee dassaa ( what can I tell)…… my full body is paining!!!
Sonia: Why…… hope like Amrinder you too are not looking for 'an all expense paid' holiday….. I told him 'no' and he says I told him 'go'!!!
Manmohan: Oh nothing like that ji……. the other day my brother was to arrive and I forgot to send the car and he caught an auto rickshaw and landed up at 7 Race Course Gate….. the already paranoid Security was giving him a hard time and just in the nick of time I came to know and I did a hundred meters dash to the gate to meet him….. since then my body's been aching!!!
Sonia: Alls well that ends well……. now lets get down to business….. who should we make the MEA????
Manmohan: Whoever we choose must have diplomatic qualities and should be presentable!!
Sonia: That rules out the person I had in mind!!!!
Manmohan: Who Madam???
Sonia: Pranab Da……. but now I see your point…. Pranab Da has a terrible temper, his dress sense is atrocious and his diction of the English language is very bad!!!
Manmohan: I understand the other points but his English diction seems to be pretty good!!
Sonia: Just ask him to say Charge Sheet and you'll understand what I'm saying????
Manmohan: Okay if by chance we do make him MEA then who will we make Defence Minister????
Sonia: Lets make Shivraj the Defence Minister….. he's been a lackluster HM but he may do wonders as a Defence Minister because he has a love for guns….. you know that they call him Gunman Shivraj!!!
Manmohan: Then who will we make the Home Minister???
Sonia: This Jairam fellow has been pestering me for the Finance Portfolio…… whenever he meets me he starts reminding me of the last general elections and how he managed the show ……. lets make him the FM and make PC the HM!!!
Manmohan: Madam if you make Jairam the FM then here's my resignation…… I feel PC is doing a good job as FM …. why shift him????
Sonia: We are just discussing the options……. okay lets make S.M. Krishna the MEA!!!
Manmohan: Yes we can send Arjun Singh as the Governor of Maharashtra……..and the HRD Portfolio can go to Pranab Da as I feel he can handle the Quota activists effectively.
Sonia: Or why don't we make Kapil Sibal the MEA….. he's got the gift of the gab, is a natty dresser and has diplomatic qualities…. the only thing is that he's pretty junior to be catapulted to MEA!!!
Manmohan: And then the Lawyer Lobby will be nitpicking our foreign police….. Jaitley, Jethmalani and the likes .….. professional jealousies amongst them runs very deep!!!
Sonia: Why don't we make PC the MEA????
Manmohan: Well as long as Jairam is not his replacement I feel this option is good!!!
Sonia: But PC will have to switchover to the MEA attire…….. and he does lack diplomacy!!!
Manmohan: Dealing with figures this does happen….. I recall when I was the FM I too had become rude…….. I think the numerical balancing that a FM has to do does create an imbalance in the FM's attitude… we have to be very patient with numbers and so we become impatient with everything else!!!!
Sonia: How about making Shivraj the MEA……he has a good command of English ,he dresses nattily and is diplomatic….. and he'll do a better job than Natwar!!!
Manmohan: But Madam you know of his shortcomings as HM…… achcha anyway who will we replace him as HM….. and speaking of Natwar…. Madam you need to drop him from all the Committees that you've nominated him on or he's going to keep turning up for the Meetings……see what he did when we held the Rajiv Gandhi Sadbhavana Committee Meeting!!!!
Sonia: Yes yes I'm dropping him………Pranab Da can be the HM!!!
Manmohan: And who will we make the Defence Minister???
Sonia: How about PC?????
Manmohan: And who will we make MF????
Sonia: Who do you suggest???
Manmohan: How about Montek???
Sonia: No…..you've expressed your allergy for Jairam so I won't suggest his name…… how about Kamalnath????
Manmohan: And who will we give the Commerce and Industry Portfolios to???
Sonia: Commerce we can give to Munshi and Industry to Ambika.
Manmohan: And we can induct three youngsters and give them Independent Charge of Parliamentary Affairs , I&B and Tourism.
Sonia: Which youngsters do you suggest????
Manmohan: Rahul can take over the I&B Ministry, Scindia the Parliamentary Affairs and Jindal the Tourism Ministry!!!
Sonia: But Rahul does not want to enter the Cabinet at this stage!!!!
Manmohan : Sonia ji just looking into the options!!!
Sonia: Have you noticed that we've practically envisaged a major reshuffle to fill in the MEA post!!!!
Manmohan: Madam ji if we want to get someone from within in the Cabinet to fill in the MEA post then as you can see we'll have to undertake a reshuffle ….. however if we get a new face then we won't have to undertake a reshuffle… like we can make Rahul the Minister of State in MEA and I'll retain the MEA and teach him the ropes!!!
Sonia: No I want to change some portfolios……. so why don't we get someone from inside the Cabinet and term this 'reshuffle' as 'readjustment' or 'relocation'????
Manmohan: Wah Sonia ji aap ji daa jawab nahi!!!!

Bharat Kumar

aaj_ki_aawaz@rediffmail.com

WHISPERS .... CORPORATE WORLD

Finally Prashanto Banerjee goes

Finally GAIL CMD Prashanto Banerjee was denied extension in his tenure.
( We said this on June 20 )

Rao appointed acting CMDof GAIL

Seniormost Director in the GAIL S P Rao has been appointed acting CMD.
( We said this on August 24 )

Is the PM listening? BHEL spends cores in his name !

BHEL's mother unit at Bhopal is spending crores of rupees for decking up a portion of it's vast township for the proposed PM's visit on it's Golden Jubliee falling on August 29. Though the visit of PM is not yet confirmed, Rs 1.4 crore is being spend on construction of a `Pandal' for him and a contract of Rs 40 lakh has been given for the printing of invitations while thousands of people living in the BHEL township in Bhopal are suffering for almost a month due to undeclared day long power cuts owing to the ongoing work at the Pandal site. "BHEL doesn't have money for the maintenance of township including employees' quarters and roads full of pot holes but it's handful officials are spending crores of hard earned money for their own welfare", employees lament.

Sukhdev appointed in Deutsche Bank

Pavan Sukhdev has been appointed as Head of Global Markets of the Deutsche Bank.

Peter is GM of Federal Bank

IPE Peter has been appointed new General Manager of Federal Bank. He is now posted at the Corporate Office.

Low, low last minute fares from Indian

Spot Fares now from 22 cities
Flying by Indian has got more exciting. Never before low fares are now available for last minute travel from as many as 22 cities.
Spot Fares, introduced from 1st Aug. 2006 on flights out of the metros - Delhi, Mumbai, Kolkata, Chennai, Hyderabad and Bangalore - have now been extended to flights departing from 16 more cities. These cities are Ahmedabad, Kochi, Bhubaneshwar, Lucknow, Nagpur, Madurai, Guwahati, Chandigarh, Pune, Thiruvananthapuram, Patna, Jaipur, Goa, Visakhapatnam, Agartala, and Bhopal.
Available on a "first come, first served" basis a few hours before the scheduled departure of a flight, these fares are available on flights that have unutilized capacity till a few hours before departure. Passengers can buy the tickets through travel agents, through the 24 X 7 toll free number 1800 180 1407, on-line or even at the airport. A boon indeed for those making last minute plans ! These fares are available till 30th Sept.2006.