| The
whispersinthecorridors Online Print from origin : whispersinthecorridors.com > Archive > 10 November 2006 , Friday |
| What people say about us ! Very
informative, useful. ONLY SOURCE
TO REACH THE DECISION MAKERS IN THE COUNTRY ADVERTISE
ON-WHISPERSINTHECORRIDORS.COM Jadhav
to continue in GoI Sudeep Banerjee appointed
Advisor Performance based remuneration
? Review
of 1985 and 1986 batch IAS likely Aulakh may be Punjab DG next year Padamvir Singh to join GoI Will
Prasad return to Orissa ? Sikkim cadre IAS to join Chhattisgarh Govt. Raje's worship at Hindu sentiment's cost Retirement age of CAT Chairman to be 67 Cabinet Secretary
orders investigations ? IPS changes in TamilNadu Bharadwaj
is back to West Bengal Kaushik gets new assignment No secr from Rajasthan FORUM I don't think that anybody doubts that some
of the better brains in the country makes it to IAS and the service has a number
of brilliant minds and some very hardworking and sincere officers who r working
in tough working conditions and contributing to nation building. In question is
the premise that only IAS officers have the competency and skills to man all the
senior level positions in the country and the service should control rest of the
services or rather the rest of the services should work in subordination to IAS.
The present regime is the reflection of the famous Indian saying 'andha bante
mungfali mur mur apno ko de'. That's how all these ridiculous rules like two years
differential in empanelment etc have been created to systematically bar the other
services for being selected as Secretaries to Govt of India. World over the trend
is to make bureaucracy as broad based as possible with a healthy mix of generalists
and specialists whereas our trend is on the reverse with the gradual depeletion
of specialist services from the top echeleons of governance. It has to be understood
that certain areas like commerce, health, finance, science and technology, telecommunications,
power etc do need an understanding of the subject from its top man and shd be
generally manned by the specialists of the subject if we r not to end up with
a total policy confusion on these critical areas. Our own experience with our
economy serves as example its only when we had Dr Manmohan Singh and Chidambaram
headed the MoF that economy witnessed the maximum growth. It's high time that
our selection process be de-linked from the service specific selection to 'best-man
mans the job' approach ir-respective of his service background. He retired mere Director and ----- Interesting to read Murali's missive.
Apropos the management Pool Murali is talking about, I have two observations.
First, I know of a topper of one of the earlier batches of the Civil Services
Exam, who joined the Management pool after doing his MBA from Harvard, and having
cleared the Civil Services Exam for the IAS/IFS thinking he was suited for it
and would serve the country better (at similar ranks, topper that he was, his
friends joined the Indian Foreign Service as was the trend in those days). The
idea of the Management Pool was stillborn. Years later, this poor chap retired
as a mere Director in the Government of India, his friends who had ranks lower
than his in the exam, retired as full Secretaries to the Government. Secondly,
the same is the case of the IAAS (Audit and Accounts Service), which was originally
meant (Nehru and his dreams!)to man senior positions in the Public sector etc,
never was it allowed to reach its potential. The solution to internecine inter
service rivalry (which has been around from the days of the ICS which used to
make life difficult for the Political Service, for example) is probably to have
smaller Services, and second suitable senior people from all Services to a common
pool to man senior positions in the Government of India. I do not see it happening
in a hurry though and perhaps it will never happen. CVC
has done good job corporate Two
vacancies of Director in INDIA Dasgupta to be ED Jhanwar is EP Indian Rayon Carbajal is Director Bata TRAI office shifts |
|
Dr
Suresh Mehrotra has his lips sealed, if you have any whispers then send it to
us |
| ©
www.whispersinthecorridors.com. (ANN) All rights reserved. |