|
What people say about us!
It is very interesting and informative site which keeps every one updated
with the developments taking place. Most of the whispers turn out to
be correct. It is very authentic and trustworthy.
Ram Nath
POLITICS
Will Cabinet meeting revoke Durga Shakti's suspension today?
A section of bureaucracy makes it a buzz whether the UP Cabinet meeting
scheduled to be held in Lucknow on August 1 would chose to revoke the
suspension of Durga Shakti or not. The spectators make it a point that
the UP Govt's stand may either bridge the divide or broaden the divide
between the government and administration.
Jharkhand may witness Cabinet expansion likely
on Aug 3?
The cabinet expansion of newly formed Government of Jharkhand is expected
on August 3.
Jairam is poised for Chairperson, Coordination
Committee for Jharkhand
Jairam Ramesh may be appointed as the Chairperson of the Coordination
Committee for the newly installed coalition government in Jharkhand
after August 4. Though he had been coordinating the affairs informally
but reportedly, he may formally be declared as the Chairperson immediately
after the cabinet expansion.
Eliminating fuel subsidies to cause impact
on incomes of households
The current approach to fuel pricing in India has resulted in large
fuel subsidies. These subsidies increased sharply from around 0.8 percent
of GDP in 2009/10 to 1.9 percent of 20 GDP in 2011/12. As well as being
fiscally costly, these subsidies are both inefficient and inequitable.
However, eliminating them will have a substantial negative impact on
the real incomes of households, estimated to range from 4 percent for
the lowest income groups to 5 percent for higher income groups.
BUREAUCRACY
Kaun Banega ONGC Chairman (4) Shashi Shankar
Shashi Shankar, who is Director (T &FS ) of the ONGC, is also in
the run for the post. He is also an insider. Interviews for the position
are expected to be held on August 30 by the Public Enterprise Selection
Board (PESB).
Arvind Ranjan gets additional charge of DG,
CRPF
DG, NSG, Arvind Ranjan, has been given additional charge of the DG,
CRPF.He will take over on Thursday.
Dilip Trivedi to be new DG of CRPF?
Latest information says that Dilip Trivedi is being appointed new DG
of the CRPF.The1978 batch IPS officer of UP cadre Trivedi is presently
Special DG, BSF.
Lawmkunga is new Chief Secretary of Manipur
P C Lawmkunga has been appointed as the new Chief Secretary of Manipur.
He succeeds D S Poonia, the incumbent CS of Manipur. Lawmkunga is a
1979 batch IAS officer of Manipur Tripura cadre.
(We said this on July 9, 2013)
Arunachal Pradesh Chief Secretary gets extension
Arunachal Pradesh Chief Secretary Dr Hari Krishna has been given six
months extension in service. A 1981 batch UP cadre IAS officer, Dr Krishna
was scheduled to retire on July 31.
(We said this on July 26, 2013)
19 IRS officers posted as Commissioners of
C&CE after promotion
As many as 19 officers of Indian Revenue Service of Customs & Central
Excise have been given postings after promotion to the grade of Commissioner
of Customs and Central Excise. The officers are: P K Goel has been appointed
as ADG, DGICCE, Kolkata; A K Roy as Commissioner (L&J), CBEC, Delhi;
M Ponnusamy as ADG, NACEN, Chennai; A M Sahay as Commissioner, Kolkata
CX-2; A R S Kumar as Commissioner Trichy Cus (P); Amand Shah as Commissioner,
Trichy CX (A); Atul Gupta-II as ADG (Audit), Mumbai; Chandra Prakash
Goyal as ADG, Kanpur, NACEN; Deepak Garg as ADG, HRD (I&W), Delhi;
G P Chandolia as Commissioner Cochin CX (A); J P Mamgain as Commissioner,
Lucknow CX (A); K P Misra as Commissioner Shillong CX; K V S Singh as
ADG, DRI, Kolkata; Krishna Pratap Singh as ADG, DGEP, Delhi; L Satya
Srinivas as ADG, Audit, Delhi; M K Srivastava as Commissioner, NOIDA
CX; M Sridhar Reddy as Commissioner, Thiruvananthapuram CX; M Subramanium
as Commissioner Mangalore CX and Madan Mohan Singh has been posted as
Commissioner, Kolkata CX 6.
Pillai is Adviser (Finance),Telecom Commission
Nirmala Pillai has been appointed as Adviser (Finance) Telecom Commission.
The 1979 batch IP&TAFS officer is serving as Principal Controller
of Communication Accounts posted in Delhi.
Tejveer Singh promoted in LBSNAA
Tejveer Singh, Deputy Director, (Sr) in the La1 Bahadur Shastri National
Academy of Administration (LBSNAA), Mussoorie has been promoted as Joint
Director in the Academy. He is 1994 batch IAS officer of Punjab cadre.
Ranjana Chopra promoted in LBSNAA
Ms Ranjana Chopra, Deputy Director, (Sr) in the Lal Bahadur Shastri
National Academy of Administration (LBSNAA), Mussoorie has been promoted
as Joint Director in the Academy. She is a 1994 batch IAS officer of
Odisha cadre.
Jharkhand CM soon to appoint OSD & APS
for Delhi affairs
As the grapevine has it Hemant Soren, the newly appointed Chief Minister
of Jharkhand is all set to appoint an OSD and an APS to be placed in
Delhi. They would take care of the CM's affairs in Delhi at Jharkhand
Bhawan.
Justice Tataia to retire on August 3
Justice Prakash Tatia, Chief Justice of Jharkhand High Court, is all
set to retire on August 3. Will he?
A P Panda joins as Director (Finance), SECL
today
A P Panda, AGM, RINL, is joining as Director (Finance), South Eastern
Coalfields Limited (SECL) on August 1, 2013. He will succeed A R Komawar.
(We said this on January 30, 2013)
Krishna Shankar joins as Director (IS&P),
BHEL today
W V K Krishna Shankar, ED, BHEL, is joining as Director (Industrial
Systems & Products), Bharat Heavy Electricals Limited (BHEL) on
August 1, 2013. He will succeed M K Dubey.
(We said this on January 29, 2013)
Sridhar Patra to join as Director (Fin), THDCIL
on Aug 2
Sridhar Patra, GM, MRPL, is joining as Director (Finance), THDC India
Limited (THDCIL) on August 2, 2013. He will succeed C P Singh.
(We said this January 11, 2013)
A K Tyagi joins as CMD, MECON Ltd today
A K Tyagi, Director (Commercial), MECON, is joining as Chairman and
Managing Director, MECON Limited, on August 1, 2013. He will succeed
K K Mehrotra.
(We said this on January 10, 2013)
Bhaskar joins as Director (Prod), BDL today
V U Bhaskar GM, BDL, is joining as Director (Production), Bharat Dynamics
Limited (BDL) on August 1, 2013. He will succeed P K Srivastava.
He is an M. Tech in Polymer Science & Technology from IIT, Delhi.
Prior to this, he did B.Tech in Plastics Technology and Chemical Engineering
from HBTI, Kanpur. He is a recipient of the prestigious Raksha Mantris
Innovation Award in Group/Individual Category for the year 2010
11 for his distinguished contribution in establishing Ballistic Evaluation
Method using T-72 fixed firing stand for indigenisation of explosive
charges of Invar Missiles.
(We said this on January 8, 2013)
Change of ADG (Law & Order) unlikely in
UP Police?
As against the recent whispers regarding the supposed change of ADG,
Law & Order; the fresh buzz suggests that Arun Kumar, 1985 batch
IPS officer, would continue with the present assignment. Recently two
names had resurfaced as the replacement of Kumar namely: Mukul Goyal
and R K Vishwakarma who are 1987 & 1988 batch IPS officers respectively.
One can only wait and watch?
Will Rizwan be the new DGP of UP?
Whispers in the corridors of power have it that Rizwan Ahmed is also
in the fray for DGP slot. He is a 1978 batch IPS officer of UP cadre
currently serving as DG, Railways. Will he win the race?
P C Jain posted as OSD before joining as Director
(Mktg), BEL
P C Jain, GM, BEL, has been appointed as OSD before joining as Director
(Marketing), Bharat Electronics Limited (BEL). Jain will succeed present
incumbent H N Ramakrishna on September 1, 2013.
43 IRS officers promoted as C&CE Commissioners
As many as 43 officers of Indian Revenue Service of Customs & Central
Excise for the panel year 2012-13 have been promoted to the grade of
Commissioner of Customs and Central Excise. The officers are: Sansar
Chand, K P Misra, J P Mamgain, A M Sahay, Shailendra Sharma, V K Singh-I,
Sudhir Kumar, G P Chandolia, Satish Kumar, R S Meena, Amand Shah, Chandra
Prakash Goyal, Prachi Saroop, A R S Kumar, Priya V K Singh, Rimjhim
Prasad, Deepak Garg, Rajesh Jindal, Satya Prasad Sahu, Simmi Jaini,
U Niranjan, Krishna Pratap Singh, P N Tiwari, P Anjani Kumar, Sunil
Tated, M K Srivastava, Atul Gupta-II, Mayank Kumar, Alok Chopra, Madan
Mohan Singh, Sharwan Kumar, L Satya Srinivas, Arti A Srinivas, Charul
Barnwal, Rajiv Ranjan, K V S Singh, M Subramanium, M Sridhar Reddy,
Capt. Sanjay Gahlot, P V Subba Rao, Sanjay Rathi, Nitish Kumar Sinha
and Shailendra Kumar Sinha.
D K Samantaray relieved to join central deputation
Madhya Pradesh Government has relieved D K Samantaray of cadre responsibility
and paved the way for joining as Chief Executive Officer, Food, Safety
and Standard Authority of India on central deputation. He is a 1982
batch IAS officer.
(We said this on July 6, 2013)
Dr Birdi is also Chairman, Vyapam
Dr Devraj Birdi has been given an additional charge of Chairman of Madhya
Pradesh Professional Examination Board (Vyapam). He is a 1982 batch
IAS officer of Madhya Pradesh cadre.
Posts of eight CITs re-designated in Chennai
Posts of eight Commissioners of Income Tax (CIT) have been re-designated
in Chennai. Accordingly, J Sirikumar has been re-designated as CIT (A),
Central-I, Chennai; Vikram Gaur as CIT (A) Central, Chennai; K Krishnamurthy
as CIT (A)-I, Chennai; Uppalapati Anjanyeyalu as CIT (A)-II, Chennai;
E S Nagendran Prasad as CIT (A)-III, Chennai; Joe Sebastian as CIT (A)-IV,
Chennai; Pathalavath Peerya as CIT (A)-VII, Chennai and M Krishnasamy
was re-designated as CIT (A)-VII, Chennai.
Two IRS-IT officers locally shifted
Two officers of Indian Revenue Service of Income Tax cadre have locally
been shifted. Krishna Kumar Tiwari has been posted as CIT-16, Mumbai
while Balakrishnan B R will now be DIT (Inv)-I, Mumbai CCA.
Three IRS-IT officers get additional charges
Three officers of Indian Revenue Service of Income Tax (IRS-IT) cadre
have been given additional charges. Accordingly, Abhay Kumar Tayal has
been assigned an additional charge of DIT (ITSC)-II, Mumbai while B
V Gopinath gets an additional charge of CIT (IB), Hyderabad and Sudhir
Kumar was given an additional charge of CIT (Burdwan) and CIT (Durgapur),
Kolkata CCA.
Will Sansi be ED, Punjab and Sindh Bank?
Kishore Sansi, General Manager, (Government Accounts Department),OBC
is likely to be ED, Punjab Sindh Bank.
Athmaram to be ED, Bank of Maharashtra ?
R Athmaram, GM, Andhra Bank is likely to be appointed to be ED of Bank
of the Maharashtra.
New post created in DDA
A new post of Principal Commissioner (Monitoring & Coordination)
has been created in Delhi Development Authority (DDA).
Mukherjee poised for Principal Commissioner,
DDA
Ranjan Mukherjee is all set to join DDA as Principal Commissioner (Monitoring
& Coordination). Previously he served as OSD to Tejendra Khanna,
previous Lieutenant Governor, Delhi. He is a Group Captain rank officer,
Indian Air Force.
Special fund for buying shares of HMT
Government of India has created a special fund in order to buy shares
of loss making PSU, HMT.
Ajit Kumar to be elevated Indian Navy
Eastern Fleet Commander P Ajit Kumar is being elevated in the Indian
Navy.
Eight IRSME officers get fresh postings
As many as eight officers of Indian Railway Service of Mechanical Engineers
(IRSME) have been given fresh postings. Accordingly, A K Gupta, SAG/IRSME/East
Coast Railway, on being relieved from the post of DRM/SBP, has been
transferred to North Central Railway and posted in the cadre while R
L Gupta, SAG/IRSME/East Central Railway, on being relieved from the
post of DRM/Sonepur, is being posted to South East Central Railway and
posted in the cadre and L C Trivedi, SAG/IRSME/South East Central Railway,
on being relieved from the post of DRM/BSP, was transferred to Western
Railway and posted in the cadre. Similarly, Rahul Jain, SAG/IRSME/South
Western Railway, on being relieved from the post of the DRM/Hubli, has
been transferred to Central Railway and posted in the cadre; T P Singh,
SAG/IRSME/South Central Railway, on being relieved from the post of
DRM/Guntakal, is transferred to North Western Railway and posted in
the cadre; Ramesh Kumar, SAG/IRSME/North Western Railway, is posted
as CME(CHOD)/North Western Railway; Sandeep Mehra, SAG/IRSME, on being
relieved from the post of ADRM/SBC/South Western Railway, posted as
Chairman RRB/Bangalore; P U K Reddy, SAG/IRSME, Chairman/RRB/Bangalore,
should be posted as Chairman/RRB/Secunderabad and C M Rao, SAG/IRSME/East
Coast Railway, on being relieved from the post of ADRM/WAT, was transferred
to Western Railway and posted in the cadre.
K B Agarwal posted Principal Resident Commissioner
of J&K to Delhi (UPDATED)
K B Agarwal has been appointed as Principal Resident Commissioner of
Jammu and Kashmir, New Delhi. He is a 1985 batch IAS officer.
Reshuffle of IAS officers in J&K (UPDATED)
Some officers of Indian Administrative Service (IAS) have been transferred
and posted at different places in Jammu and Kashmir. Accordingly, Ms
Sonali Kumar has been appointed as Chairperson, J&K Special Tribunal
while Shantamanu will now be Divisional Commissioner, Jammu and Ms Sarita
Chauhan is Secretary, Animal & sheep Husbandry. Similarly, M A Bukhari
has been appointed as Secretary, GAD, Sheikh Mushtaq as Secretary, Higher
Education; Saurabh Bhagat as Secretary, Industries & Commerce; Saugat
Biswas as MD, J&K Medical Supplies Corporation; Shyam Vinod Meena
as Additional Secretary, PHE, Irrigation and Food Control.
12th NTPC Professional Circle Convention inaugurated
(UPDATED)
Arup Roy Choudhury, CMD inaugurated the 12th NTPC Professional Circle
Convention. I J Kapoor, Director (Commercial), B P Singh, Director (Projects)
N N Misra, Director (Operations) A K Jha, Director (Tech.)) UP Pani,
Director (HR) were present with him on the occasion. Professional Circles
provide a platform for sharing and dissemination of knowledge among
NTPC executives to keep them abreast of latest developments while leveraging
their efforts to address business problems and challenges. Sixteen winner
teams of all regional level conventions participated in this company
level convention held recently. Awards were presented to the Successful
Professional Circles - Apex from Farakka, Gyanoday of NETRA, Ankur from
Faridabad. Southern Region and Eastern Region were also awarded on the
occasion
Ms Richa Gaharwar posted as Dy Secretary,
CBDT (UPDATED)
Ms Richa Gaharwar( JCIT, IRS) has been deputed as Deputy Secretary (V&I)
in Central Board of Direct Taxes, Department of Revenue on deputation
basis.
Mrs Anita Kaul assumes charges as Secretary,
Law and Justice (UPDATED)
Mrs Anita Kaul has taken over as the Secretary, Department of Justice
in the Ministry of Law & Justice. Before joining the Department
of Justice, Mrs Kaul was the Principal Secretary Planning in the Programme
Implementation Department of the Government of Karnataka. She is a 1979
batch IAS officer of Karnataka cadre.
(We said this on July 4, 2013)
Mrs Sujatha Singh joins as Foreign Secretary
(UPDATED)
Mrs Sujatha Singh has taken over as new Foreign Secretary, Ministry
of External Affairs. She is a 1976 batch officer of Indian Foreign Service
(IFS).
(We said this on April 10 & June 26, 2013)
Prof Waman Kendre posted as Director, NSD
(UPDATED)
Professor Waman Kendre has been appointed as Director of National School
of Drama (NSD) for a period of five years.
Rajesh Agarwal selected as Director (W&W),
KRCL (UPDATED)
Rajesh Agarwal, ED, KRCL, has been selected for the post of Director
(Way & Works), Konkan Railway Corporation Limited (KRCL) at a Public
Enterprises Selection Board (PESB) meeting held on August 1, 2013. As
many as 12 persons were interviewed for the same.
CORPORATE
Shah appointed Independent Director, Gujarat Pipavav Port Limited
Gujarat Pipavav Port Limited has appointed Ms Hina Shah as Independent
Director of the company.
Malhotra appointed Addl. Director, HCL Technologies
Limited
HCL Technologies Limited has appointed Ms Roshni Nadar Malhotra as the
Additional Director of the company.
Ratnaparkhi appointed CFO, Finolex Industries
Limited
Finolex Industries Limited has appointed Mandar B Ratnaparkhi, Vice
President(Finance & Accounts) as the Chief Financial Officer (CFO)
of the company w.e.f. August 1, 2013
Joshua appointed Company Secretary, Morepen
Laboratories Ltd
Morepen Laboratories Limited has appointed Thomas P Joshua as the Company
Secretary of the company.
Maniar resigns as Non Exec. Director, Varun
Shipping Company Ltd
C M Maniar has resigned as Non-Executive Director of Varun Shipping
Company Ltd on his personal grounds
Subbarao appointed Independent Director, Educomp
Solutions Ltd
Educomp Solutions Ltd has appointed Dr V V Subbarao as Independent Director
of the company.
Balasubramanian ceases to be Director, Mafatlal
Industries Ltd
V K Balasubramanian has ceased to be Director of Mafatlal Industries
Ltd.
Surana appointed Addl. Director, Madhusudan
Industries Ltd
Madhusudan Industries Ltd has appointed Prem Chand Surana as an Additional
Director of the company.
Mohata resigns as Director of Madhusudan Industries
Ltd
Narayan Mohata has resigned as Director of Madhusudan Industries Ltd.
Kohli ceases to be Company Secy,Advance Metering
Technology Ltd
Jaspreet Singh Kohli has ceased to be the Company Secretary of Advance
Metering Technology Ltd.
FORUM
(The views expressed in this column are of
the contributors. We do not owe any responsibility, whatsoever, of the
views of our surfers as they are their personal opinion. However, we
would also request our contributors not to be personal, directly or
indirectly, in presenting their views. Instead of countering the views
which X has already expressed, our contributors are advised
to present their own views. Also be brief, say about 200 words at the
most since any views longer than that if eliminated at our end would
carry the risk of the contrbutors item losing its original essence)
Justice of an IAS officer against an IAS officer
The question is as to who has made Durga Shakti- 'Shaktiless'. I do
not find fault in politicians as the suspension order must have been
passed by an IAS officer and an IAS officer is expected to do justice.
One should not doubt the decision of an IAS officer and if the suspension
order is not valid, the Secretary passing the impugned order is not
fit for the post in my opinion and we should cry for that only.
S K Singh
Suspension of IAS officer a dangerous trend
Suspension of Ms Durga Shakti Nagpal, an IAS officer of UP cadre, is
a dangerous trend. Either, the Allahabad High Court or the Supreme Court
should have suo-moto taken up the incident of suspension of Ms Durga
Shakti Nagpal as a case of PIL and issued notice to the UP Government.
The biggest casualty of illegal mining taking place along the rivers
is the 'environment'. Where are the propoganist of environment? Why
are they not shouting from the top? "A la Sunita Narain of Centre
for Science and Environment".
Satya Prakash
Victimization of lady officer
The lady IAS officer has been suspended without calling for an explanation.
The Chief Secretary should not consider that he cannot be treated in
the same manner if the situation is so arrived. In Govt working if any
action has to be taken against even a peon. First explanation is called
for the violation of any rules. In case reply is not satisfactory then
a memo is served why action should not be taken against you for such
and such lapse. Here is case where punishment has been awarded without
calling even for an explanation. What is this working? What it shows?
Let the officer should request for central deputation which will be
the best option for her at this moment. We should be more sensitive
in such matters.
N Prakash
Victimization of officers not reported in media
It is not understood why so much hue and cry there on suspension of
an IAS officer in UP. In reality there are many officers and staff are
victimized which have been either not reported or got unnoticed by the
media. Specially the lower rung staff who have been victimised in the
same way.
Kalyan
Alok Ranjan makes everyone in IAS coterie ashamed
Alok Ranjan, an IAS officer of 1978 batch, has made everyone in IAS
ashamed holding charge as Acting Chief Secretary in UP. A thoroughly
weak officer who suspended an upright IAS young girl Durga Shakti Nagpal.
R C Srivastava IAS
Alok Ranjan is a blot on IAS
Alok Ranjan is a blot on IAS. As Acting Chief Secretary, he was instrumental
in suspending her. Jawed Usmani the CS is on leave for 5 days. Alok
Ranjan wants to be CS and is holding the powerful posts of APC and IDC
and also the President of IAS UP Association and CM's sycophant.
A Goyal IAS
Ranjan tried to appease UP CM
The present Acting Chief Secretary, Alok Ranjan (IAS 1978) fooled all
of us and was instrumental in suspending Durga Shakti Nagpal (IAS 2010).
Trying to appease the CM UP. Unfortunate for IAS in UP.
P Sen Sharma
Ranjan fools IAS Association
Alok Ranjan (IAS 1978) is Agriculture Production Commissioner (APC),
Industrial Development Commissioner (IDC) and several other portfolios
and President IAS Association. He fooled IAS Association by saying that
he will take the case to CM. What a pity.
R S Nigam IAS
Politicians make bureaucrats dance to their tunes
The suspension of young IAS probationer in UP is a strong indicator
to the fact that it is the top echelon of our bureaucracy which is intellectually
bankrupt and morally weak. This again prove how politicians can make
them to dance to their tunes. But it needs a spine of steel to refuse
to the tunes of political masters but corrupt and self centered bureaucrats
always look for the shortcuts. It is such bureaucracy which has let
the country down. Political masters would have fallen the line had these
white collared burden to the exchequer proven their integrity and commitment
towards the people. Such people in the echelon should be identified
and exposed on public domain. Righteous and impartial officers must
hold the baton of bureaucracy.
Chanakya
Poonia proves his mettle
Poonia will be remembered for his hard work and sincerity to the state.
Best wishes for new inning sir.
Komal Singh
MEA should improve performance in Passport
I fully agree. MEA should improve on performance in each sphere but
passport is of prime importance as this is where is public knows existence
of MEA. Should devise a system wherein New Passport be issued within
one month, if it is rejected or refused, that also be intimated to the
applicant within one month. Renewal is done 3-4 days. Other areas where
MEA needs to improve is increase in India's exports, India's investment
abroad, especially in the poor countries so that goods can be produced
and exported at competitive prices via export free zones and third country.
Each representative posted abroad must be given a target for India's
exports. This should judge his/her performance. This is a commercial
world.
Harish Kumar
Scooters India Ltd: Reforms fail to restore it to health
The curious case of Scooters India Ltd isn't this public sector unit
celebrating the 39th glorious year of its "sickness"? Even
reforms have failed to restore it to health. This case presents itself
for a research study on fair business practices in India. None of our
celebrated economists and planning czars, their think tanks or advisory
councils, have ever pronounced on such cases of economic miseries inflicted
on the aam aadmi & the tax payer. We are so cute a country!
M L Gupta
IAS officer causes sufferings of IAS officer
It is indeed a long awaited rendering of justice for Shetty. It is
a pity that another IAS officer was the cause of all this suffering
of Shetty.
S Ramasundaram
Neither Mulayam nor Lalu is Dalit leader
Neither Mulayam Singh nor Lalu is Dalit leader. They are neither Dalit
nor leaders of Dalits alone. Behenji is a Dalit leader and, it must
be added, a great achiever despite being a woman and a Dalit both of
which categories have suffered greatly in the past before our constitution
came into force (though now empowered through our constitution). Meira
Kumarji is a leader of great stature of all communities, castes and
religions and it is wrong to fetter her as merely a Dalit leader.
Vijay Kumar
|
DATE WITH RTI
|
 |
|
As the case in the trial court then the information could
be disclosed
Referring to a trap case, the accused wanted the copy of the
FIR and the charge sheet filed from the CBI. The Public Information
Officer (PIO) refused to disclose information on the ground that
the CBI has been included in the second schedule to the RTI Act.
During the hearing before the Central Information Commission (CIC),
the respondent submitted that the prosecution in the case is pending
before the trial court and the same cannot be provided without
seeking the prior permission of the court. The CIC ruled that
the PIO cannot be directed to disclose any information in a case
of complaint under section 18 of the RTI Act.
Comments
In Chief Information Commissioner & another v. State of Manipur
& another in Civil Appeal Nos.10787-10788 of 2011, the Supreme
Court had held that Sections 18 and 19 of the RTI Act serve two
different purposes and lay down two different procedures and they
provide two different remedies. One cannot be a substitute for
the other. Under Section 18 of the RTI Act, the Information Commission
has no powers to direct the public authority to furnish the information
and such a power has already been conferred under Section 19(8)
of the Act on the basis of an exercise under Section 19 only.
Citation: Mr. Omprakash v. Central Bureau
of Investigation in File No. CIC/SM/C/2012/001167
Weekly article
by Dr (Mrs ) Anuradha Verma
(dranuradhaverma@yahoo.co.in) She is
RTI Consultant to IIM, Indore and her other articles can be read
at http://www.rtifoundationofindia.com
|
|
|
|
|
 |
|