Whispers Forum

There are news reports of people dying after falling in open pits left on roads without proper fencing or barricades. People are reported to be dying after falling in manholes left without covers. Children are being infected with HIV when transfusion of infected unscreened blood is being done in government hospitals in remote parts of the country. These are all preventable. Is it not the responsibility of officers to see to it that such things do not happen? When new recruits join the services, the motive should not be self aggrandisement and self promotion laced with hypocrisy, but public service. Only a change in mindset and a spirit of service can change things.
Vijay Kumar

BJP is already in alliance with NCP(Ajit Pawar) faction in Maharashtra. So it ain’t question of ifs and buts , it has already happened.
Pratik
Defence organization of Australia
The Australians have a different higher-defence organization than India. They have a four-star Chief of Defence Force (who plays a greater operational role), with the service chiefs being three-star officers. They focus mostly on centrally-based joint-planning, with a lot of power centralized under the CDF and his Joint Staff. We however, are trying to follow the U.S.-model, by integrating tri-service components under one commander per region. Even though Chauhan is committed to it, I estimate it'll take some mor years for the concept to mature and then gain operational exposure. So yes, it will take time.
Kishore Anandan

FIRE (Financial Independence, Retire Early) focuses on aggressive saving and smart investing. For many investors, the FIRE movement, Financial Independence Retire Early, sounds like the perfect escape plan, especially freedom from the 9-to-5 grind. Save aggressively, invest smartly and break free from work, decades ahead of schedule. But once real-life expenses, family responsibilities and rising costs enter the picture, the classic FIRE formula often feels difficult to follow. This is where flexibility becomes important. Instead of forcing a rigid retirement rule, alternatives like Lean FIRE, Coast FIRE, Barista FIRE, Fat FIRE and Slow FIRE are emerging as more practical alternatives, especially for investors who want financial independence without extreme sacrifice.
Lean FIRE aims to reduce post-retirement expenses, enabling a smaller savings goal. Coast FIRE, which focuses on saving aggressively in 20s and 30s and taking lower-stress job later. This is achieved by way of investing heavily when young and let compounding do the work. Barista FIRE means not retiring fully, but earning through part-time work. It is specially meant for those who do not hate work but want freedom. Fat FIRE means retiring early without cutting lifestyle. This is best for high earners who enjoy spending. Slow FIRE means financial independence without burnout by way of moderate saving and high quality of life along the way. This is best for people who enjoy the journey more than the exit.
If classic FIRE does not work, the above types of FIRE variants offer practical, flexible alternatives to achieve financial independence. The FIRE retirement strategy rests on three pillars – saving 50-70 per cent of income, living a frugal lifestyle and investing wisely, usually through low-cost index funds. The logic is straight forward. You drastically raise your savings rate by cutting expenses then invest that surplus in diversified, low-cost funds, so compounding works in your favor. Index funds matter here because they reduce the risk of costly investment mistakes and high fees eating into long-term returns.
As FIRE is not one-size-fits-all, the biggest takeaway is that instead of chasing a rigid rule, investors should be realistic about expenses and inflation; choose a FIRE variant that fits their lifestyle and career stage; focus on disciplined investing through low-cost, diversified funds; avoid withdrawing from long-term investments prematurely. Thus, financial independence is not about quitting work at any cost. It is about building options.
No matter what the type of FIRE, there is the Universal FIRE tactics which overall aims at a savings rate of 30-70% depending on the strategy. Here, savings rate matters more than the returns. One should invest simply but consistently avoiding timing the market. Control lifestyle inflation by raising savings when income rises and spending intentionally not automatically.
Yours truly,
Subbiah Sridhar

The appellant sought information about the marks scored by him in the examination conducted for the Sub-inspector in Delhi Police, CAPFs and Assistant Sub-inspector in CISF Examination. The information was denied and on query by the CIC, the respondent submitted that it was not declared by the Appellant in his RTI Application that his result was withheld, which is why such a reply was provided to him. The appellant argued that since information related to one of the candidates has been provided, he is also entitled to access the information related to him now since the OA stands disposed of. The appellant submitted that the averred OA infructuous and the interim order that the PIO is relying upon to withhold the information of the candidates in a sealed cover was no longer stipulated to be in operation whilst passing the final order. The averred final order stipulates that all pending MA(s) are also disposed of with another connected OA being described as infructuous and this order significantly predates the date of filing of the RTI Application. Additionally, the PIO has not complied with the averred FAA’s order which was leaning in favor of the Appellant. The CIC directed the PIO to submit a written explanation to show cause as to why action should not be initiated in the matter under Section 20(1) of the RTI Act for failing to provide a proper reply to the RTI Application at the original instance as the queries of different nature i.e distinct from the mere marks and result of the Appellant were left unattended by providing an unwarranted cumulative reply. Further, the PIO was also directed to explain the prima-facie non-compliance of the FAA’s order within 15 days. The PIO was directed to provide a revised reply to the RTI Application incorporating the available information regarding the Appellant’s result and OMR sheet as sought for.
Comments
In many instances, it has been pointed out that the marks scored by an individual should be provided to him/her unless any of the exemption sections of the RTI Act, 2005 can be invoked to deny the information.
Citation: Rajesh Kumar v. Staff Selection Commission, Second Appeal No. CIC/SSCOM/A/2024/633982; Date of Decision: 10.09.2025
Dr Anuradha Verma (dranuradhaverma@yahoo.co.in) is a RTI Consultant currently working with IIM Vishakhapatnam. She has co-authored the books PIO’s Guide to RTI and Right to Information – Law and Practice. Her weekly article is being published since 2008 on this site. She offers consultancy on RTI matters and third party audit to individuals / organisations. Her other articles can be read at the website of RTI Foundation at the link https://www.rtifoundationofindia.com

The slowness of the judicial system is distorting life in the country. So is corruption in all walks of life including land administration and police. These two issues need resolution. The judiciary is the guardian of the rights of the people. Justice delayed results in justice denied. The slowness in the judiciary is in the district courts. The only way to reduce this is to recruit Additional District Judges through All India examination to ensure attracting talent into the district judiciary. This will immediately improve efficiency in the judicial system. Prior to independence, the District courts were manned by the ICS. After independence, only the provincial judicial service is ruling the roost, resulting in dearth of high quality talent. With increased complexity in administration, such dearth of talent is proving deadly to the judicial delivery system. The way to reduce corruption is less easy. The only way is to take strict action against the guilty. All India Services are not under the jurisdiction of CBI. This makes it easy for them to indulge in corruption since they are not under the oversight of the CBI. The jurisdiction of CBI must be extended to All India Services. To reduce corruption in the Central Services, the percentage of promotees therein, currently at 50% should be reduced to 33.33% on a par with the All India Services. The younger who are always more idealistic, are always less corrupt than the older. Service standards will also improve if more talented youngsters are recruited instead of having a majority of old fogeys drawn from lower ranks; just like the All India Services.
Vijay Kumar

President Trump,the unscrupulous megalomaniac, has unilaterally announced slashing tariffs on indian goods from 50 % to 18 % . Not out of friendship but,by compromising India's strategic autonomy.
This would have massive geo political implications for India which was hitherto getting crude oil from its time-tested friend Russia at discounted rate.
Indo-Russia friendship ties are bound to be adversely affected as India will now be a US ally.
Ties with BRICS members will go for a hit particularly those with Russia ,Brazil,SA and China.
Going further,in absence of any formal trade deals ,how could interests of Indian farmers’ and dairy owners’ be protected,one wonders ?Details of the deal are still to be finalized and released?
Announcing deals through the tweets is meaningless. Where are hard copies of deals, agreements and joint statements signed by the US and India?
Will the US's "Greatest of all trade deals" not adversely impact Indo-EU's "Mother of all deals"?
The public is confused.It must be taken into confidence.
We trust, the ruling dispensation will be circumspect in exercising all options.Tough times are ahead.
A K Saxena (Former civil servant)
Mrs Padmaja Priyadarshini B.N. appointed Addl. Director, Xchanging Solutions Ltd
Priyadarshini is a self disciplined, Time Conscious, participative, collaborative, strategic, empathetic, growth oriented, solution seeking, intellectual, Adaptive, flexible, committed and down to field professional, capable of handling any managerial decision making situations aligning with the Vision and mission of the Organisation. She travelled through very difficult and challenging phases of her career and business that shaped her a well matured professional to understand the organisation and society thoroughly and giving the best of her talents to any assigned role. She never tolerate intentional disrespect. Wishing her All the best in all her endeavours.
Dr. Madhavan. S. A. CMA

This is a deadly judgment with its impact across a wide section of the government department which most people will not be able to understand. It would help in ensuring better utilization of reservation benefits and put pressure on those head of department who are not enforcing the reservation. But there is a catch - a BIG catch - disclosure of the caste of the government servant. The conflict would remain and now the issue is out in public. Let us see how it evolves. Thanks for bringing it out in public knowledge
Suresh Kumar

It is a matter requiring sober thought that reservations in education and public services are now in excess of 60% (in addition, reservations in politics are at 22.5% for SC/ST and also for OBCs in local self government institutions). No society that places no emphasis on merit can survive, what to say of growing. Reservations began for SC/STs for 10 years capped at 22.5%. There was a caveat then, that efficiency of administration should not be imperilled. Today, with the country awash in reservations without any time limit, and each political party willing to increase it both in proportion and prolong it to perpetuity, after 78 years of independence, whatever has happened to efficiency of administration? Everyone agrees that administrative efficiency has declined over the years and decades. In the rat race to give more and more reservations, education and governance have been given the short shrift. How can a country where caste determines career become a developed country? Once India became independent and the Constitution came into force, equality was mandated. A helping hand to the deprived has become a depriving hand today. At this rate, can we ever compete with China and the rest of the world? Instead of world class, we are becoming less and less competitive every day. If merit and hard work are relegated behind caste, what future do we have as a country? The time has come to think of phasing out reservations. Those who have availed of the benefit once, they should not get the benefit again. Why should someone get the benefit of becoming a doctor through reservations and then go on to join the IAS through quota? Those who have got the benefit, their children should not get the benefit. This will broad base reservations and benefit more and more candidates also.
Vijay Kumar

The appellant sought information about the SC and ST Professors currently employed at IIM Ranchi, the vacancy position, the special recruitment drives etc. which did not result into any response from the PIO. The Respondent submitted that the RTI application was forwarded to Mr. Amit Kumar, (HR), subsequently, reminders were also sent but no response had been received from him. Upon receipt of hearing notice, the information was collected from the concerned office and uploaded on the Commission’s weblink. The CIC noted that the respondent has not responded to the RTI application in spite of over 1½ years having elapsed. The reply uploaded on Commission’s web portal has not provided to the appellant. The CIC noted that the PIO has not been made any efforts to furnish a response to the appellant even upon receipt of hearing notice and he failed to explain the cogent reasons for the same. The CIC issued a Show-cause notice to PIO, Mr. Rajasekhar David, Assistant Professor, as to why action under Section 20(1) of the RTI Act should not be initiated against him for not responding to the RTI application within stipulated time.
Comments
It is disquieting that instances continue to arise where the CIC has no option but to issue show-cause notices to PIOs for neglecting to respond to RTI applications within the statutory timeframe, thereby inviting penal action under Section 20(1) of the RTI Act. If the case pertains to a premier management institute, one wonders whether it is a case of lack if awareness of the provisions of the RTI Act.
Citation: Raju Paswan v. Indian Institute of Management Ranchi, Second Appeal No. CIC/IIMRC/A/2024/643443; Date of Decision: 14.10.2025
Dr Anuradha Verma (dranuradhaverma@yahoo.co.in) is a RTI Consultant currently working with IIM Vishakhapatnam. She has co-authored the books PIO’s Guide to RTI and Right to Information – Law and Practice. Her weekly article is being published since 2008 on this site. She offers consultancy on RTI matters and third party audit to individuals / organisations. Her other articles can be read at the website of RTI Foundation at the link https://www.rtifoundationofindia.com

Longevity does not come from a single supplement, drug or hack, rather it is the cumulative effect of many small, consistent choices over time. It is not the diet, it is not the exercise and certainly it is not the genetics. The main factor behind a healthy heart, a healthy brain the entire healthy body and longevity is ‘No Chronic Stress’ rest everything else in the world is secondary. Even if you train daily, you eat healthy, you quit smoking but if you are under constant stress you will still age faster not just by your skin but also from the internal organs.
What does matter, according to the strongest evidence so far, is a combination of lifestyle fundamentals which includes regular physical activity, good sleep and stress management. Secondly, nutrition patterns, not a super food, but overall dietary quality, calorie balance and metabolic health. Thirdly avoiding major harms that is smoking, excess alcohol and chronic inactivity.
So, rule number one - do not engage into anything that is creating internal resistance. You hate your job but continue for money, minus the 15 years of life. You surround yourself with people who drain out your energy, minus the 10 years of life. Every single day living in the same toxic environment is going to age you at a considerable level. Rule number two - social connection matters more than material attachment. People who have strong social connection live longer up to fifty per cent and it is definitely not about having many friends or relations, it is about having meaningful ones. So even one person who allows you to be truly yourself can extend your life more than a diet. Rule number three - find a purpose bigger than yourself. People with a clear purpose live an average of seven years longer. And it does not have to be a big mission but a strong one because what matters is the feeling that I am here for a reason, I am needed. Rule number four - listen to your body otherwise one fine day your body will stop talking to you. Sleep when you feel sleepy, rest when you feel tired, and eat whenever you are hungry because healthier people do not punish themselves, they follow the rules but they follow the natural rhythm. It is a myth that one should have dinner by sunset and such others. Modern life teaches us to push through and rest for later but you know what, the body cannot actually endure it because it is not designed like that.
Chronic stress is actually not about work, money, success or fame or the achievements. In fact it is the biggest misconception. Chronic stress is about the inner conflict of who we are and what we want to be and what we actually pretend to be in front of others. So when we are not living with authenticity, when we are not living an honest life, the life that is truly ours, the body stays under survival mode non-stop. Cortisol destroys the blood vessels, immunity gets weaken and brain function gets damaged. So people who are actually living healthier and longer are not consuming some magic pill but because they choose to live in peace within themselves. Even the most promising longevity drugs being studied (like rapamycin or metformin) do not replace these basics, they only potentially layer on top of them and evidence in humans is still evolving.
Subbiah Sridhar