Monday, November 16, 2026
Live
“
“
Voices from the corridors

Whispers Forum

Debates, reader views and sharp takes on the issues shaping governance — a new conversation every week, archived by date.

0 posts 0 months Latest: 25 Dec 2017
  Browse by date   All posts3232
  2026235
  2025357
  2024357
  2023357
  2022351
  2021342
  2020349
  2019340
  2018332
  2017212

Forum & RTI 3,232 posts · page 253 of 270

Monday, 25 December 2017
Forum

“ 2G Scam Acquittals : Total Failure of Prosecution”

Shocking judgement by special CBI court on 2G spectrum allocation scam.
Judicial pronouncement or political narrative, one wonders ?
Bungling by CBI. Its evidences could not stand the judicial scrutiny.
Roles of high net worth industrial houses of India , is in question.
Indictment of former C&AG Vinod Rai raises more question than solve.
Sudden transfers of SP and DIG ,CBI charged with investigation of 2G scam at crucial moment ,was baffling.
“It was not A Raja, but Pulok Chatterjee, in consultation with TKA Nair, as he had suppressed the most relevant and controversial part of the letter of A Raja from the then Prime Minister,” said CBI Special Judge Saini.
Suggestions were made to the ruling dispensation to get T K A Nair, former Principal Secy and, more importantly, Pulok Chatterji, former JS, later elevated as Secretary to the then PM Manmohan Singh, interrogated by the CBI. Their earlier confessional statements to CBI had the stamp of approval of the then de facto PM.
Move to grill former PM’s aides was reportedly blocked by the all-powerful IAS fraternity. Why? And, at whose behest ? And, to protect whom ?
It will be simplistic to suggest that PM MMS was not kept in the loop by his aides. Files on policy matters and appointments were regularly shown to the Chairperson, NAC.
Pulok Chatterji wielded enormous power by virtue of his loyalty and proximity to the Cong supremo. A general factotum to the supremo, he kept shuttling between the Rajiv Gandhi Foundation and the PMO depending on which party was in power. This was an open secret much before Sanjay Baru’s memoirs “The Accidental Prime Minister, hit the stands.
In fact, Maun Maun Singh was so much enamoured of PM's chair that he chose to remain silent before formalising all oral orders of the Congress supremo, as conveyed by former PM's aides.
UPA’s caged parrot CBI remained soft to PMO officials ? It is understood that PMO officials' statements were legally and officially vetted to remain in sync with Manmohan Singh's stand. All to protect the supremo.
In order to get at the bottom of the truth, extra-ordinary steps are required against all accused. Skeletons in the cupboard will start tumbling out.
For how long could the real perpetrators be allowed to have a free run.
Any secret deal, one wonders?
The ruling political dispensation will have much to explain.
A K Saxena (A retd civil servant)
Saturday, 23 December 2017
Forum

Chilling crime stories in newspapers !

The crime stories in the newspaper are sometimes so chilling that one is left with a very disturbed mind. Rapes of young girls even little babies, murders over small issues, sons killing mothers, brothers killing sisters, the young school boys killing their school mates are daily happening. What has gone wrong with society. Human values have no meaning. Anger, greed, jealousy and ill will have become part of our character. Why? For one thing too much exposure via technology, social media and so-called entertainment industry has done more harm. Then there is no fear of law because punishment for a crime, if at all delivered, comes after a long time. Nirbhaya's culprits are still not hanged five years down the line. When Supreme Court finishes with their review petition, they still have a door to the President for mercy petition. Meanwhile they lead a leisurely life in jail. Reformed jails, it seems is a misplaced idea. With great food, regular medical check-ups, yoga, exercise, TV and busy learning some useful skill being in jail is a comfortable idea than coming out doing work and struggling in life. Incidents of some people being released and then committing another crime to get back in jail have happened. So the prison need to be made a tough place for criminals to deter the crime rate. The trouble with us is that we start bothering about the human rights of the criminals forgetting the victims of their crime.
Aarti Khosla
Steel Minister’s reply not correct
It is right time for PM to purge the frauds, corruption, casteism, regionalism, nepotism in steel Maharatna PSU. The reply given by Steel Minister in parliament for the reasons of loss making is not correct.
A Visitor
Friday, 22 December 2017
Forum

How is it personal information ?

How can asking for details of family members and the amount taken from the Government exchequer be treated as personal information. If you give wrong information relating to details about family members and claim undue amount of LTC it can be asked for. The Supreme Court in one of the case has clearly said that 'if any information of about misdeeds has been obtained by hook of crook and it turns out to be true, then it is an enough evidence under the Indian Evidence Act and the person who has done wrong can be booked. It is the corrupt in the Government who are against the RTI Act-2005
BBS
Gupta is a hard working and honest bank official
R.K. Gupta is a hard working, honest and intelligent person and hope for better working and taking the bank to its new heights in the coming time. My congrats and best wishes to Mr. Gupta.
Ram Kumar Garg
Thursday, 21 December 2017
Forum

Gujarat elections will be case study

Gujarat election will be the case study for political studies and I would say Amit Shah and Narendra Modi have finally passed the toughest political exam of their career
Bhupendra
“ Better late than never ”
Emboldened by the twin electoral victories in Gujarat and HP, PM Modi must now focus on big-ticket corruption by high- networth business houses and individuals rather than run after small rogues.
All are having a free run within India and abroad.
PM Modi won the last general elections on the plank of UPA corruption scams. He had promised to bring the guilty to book.
Some infamous scams are : Bofors, Sathyam (2009),CWG (2010), Coalgate (2012), 2G spectrum (2008) Navy war room leaks, Sathyam scam (2012), Choppers scam (2012 ), Tatra truck (2012), Adarsh scam (2012),Delhi Jal Board tanker scam - ( Rs 400 crores) wherein the Anti-Corruption Bureau has filed an FIR against former Delhi CM Sheila Dikshit and current Delhi CM Arvind Kejriwal, Saradha group financial scandal and last but not the least Robert Vadra scam . The list is endless.
These scams are crying for prosecution and convictions of perpetrators.
Precious time has been wasted by the current political dispensation, resulting in public disenchantment, disillusionment with the leadership
Is removing corruption separable from Good governance ?
A K Saxena (A retd civil servant)
Wednesday, 20 December 2017
Forum

Gujarat Mandate

People of Gujarat are well balanced & intelligent. They did not let down a world class leader which they have given. Let’s wait & watch to see who celebrates the New Year enthusiastically. I said this on Dec 5.
Vivek Dhawan
What is the role of youth in Indian politics ?
Do you think youth in Indian politics means above 40 because looking at Gujarat, three youths can only misguide society for their short term aspirations. This is serious question I am asking that what is the youth in politics ?
Bhupendra
Tuesday, 19 December 2017
Forum

Such persons be denied visa

I entirely agree. Such persons should be declared persona non grata and denied visa to enter India W/R to our own they should be publicly castigated for joining hands with an enemy. Will US allow a N Korean to do such things on its soil ? No compromise with the national integrity and honour should be allowed under any circumstance.
Ananya
This Group always work against India
Government of India should take note of this and it is high time they take strict action against them at once. They cannot hide in the name of social gathering. Hope PM is aware of all these things and may be working on it.
Seth
Monday, 18 December 2017
RTI

Information to be provided pro-actively

The appellant sought copies of recruitment Rules of NATRIP approved by Governing Council, copies of sanction posts, vacant posts and promotion policies of NATRIP approved by Governing Council, advertisement published for recruitment/tenders etc. The appellant acknowledged that he had received 1000 pages of documents but claimed that they contained either repeat pages or blank papers without providing the information sought by him. It was articulated that the information sought by him was of general nature which would have been placed in the Public Domain in accordance with Section 4 of the RTI Act, 2005 relating to suo-motu disclosure by the Public Authority. The CIC advised the Respondent to suo-motu disclose such recruitment rules/policy in public domain in compliance with Section 4 of the RTI Act to ensure transparency, credibility, objectivity and accountability in the functioning of the Public Authority.
Comments
A voluntary disclosure of all information that ought to be displayed in the public domain should be the rule and filing of RTI Application by the members of public who wish to seek information should be an exception. The Section 4(2) of the RTI Act mandates every public authority to provide as much information suo-motu to the public at regular intervals through various means of communications so that the general public need not resort to the filing of RTI Application.
Citation: Mr. S. Murli Manoharam v. National Automotive Testing & R&D Infrastructure Project, Ministry of Heavy Industries & Public Enterprises in Appeal No.:-CIC/NATRI/A/2017/117839-BJ, Date of Decision: 30.11.2017
Dr. Anuradha Verma (dranuradhaverma@yahoo.co.in) is the co-author of the books: RIGHT TO INFORMATION – LAW AND PRACTICE and PIO’s guide to RTI. Her other articles can be read at the website of RTI Foundation of India at - http://www.rtifoundationofindia.com/
Forum

PM Modi will win a three fourths majority in Gujarat.

Vijay Kumar
ECI is not able to discipline ,very sad
ARC Kumar
Befitting reply for Congress
I am sure that the people of Gujarat will give a befitting reply to the Congress for trying to denigrate a PM, who is not only honest, but most popular not only in the country but the world. I am sure many others would like our PM to continue after 2019, rather than have so called educated/intellectuals, whose only objective is to plunder this country and play against the sentiments of the majority community.
S Chatterjee
Saturday, 16 December 2017
Forum

Will DMs take crime meetings in UP ?

What is wrong with this ? After all we are not living in a police state and the district level functionaries have to be accountable.
Amitabh Agrawal
Who will be new Chief Secretary of Rajasthan ?
I think Gupta stands a better chance...Scindia may want a woman CS...but logic will prevail.
Vineet
Friday, 15 December 2017
Forum

British legacy of supremacy continues

The British legacy of supremacy of IAS over other services continues despite more than 70 years of independence. DMs never oversee crime and order situations but they boss over IPS officers even much senior to them. This must change right away.
Parth
It’s a permanent fixture
It is not for the first time that Kasuri was in India and feasted by his close friend Mani Shankar Aiyer. He is here every second month a permanent fixture in any seminar or talk on the subject of indo-Pak relations. As a matter of fact, for some persons particularly a Gentleman based in Calcutta, holding such meetings on Kashmir and Indo-Pak relations is a regular business. Not only such meetings are held here where this group which includes Mani Shankar and others like him meet but their "friends" in Pakistan also reciprocate the step by holding these 'get-togethers' in Pakistan which are then attended by this group. Kasuri of course is always presiding over the meetings here. The gentleman from Calcutta who is running the Kashmir conflict business mentions this on the invitation card he hands over to people around to get an audience. One such meeting was scheduled at India International centre on the date after the Pathankot attack. I thought the organizer of this meeting would cancel these indo-Pak talks to be held in one of the Committee rooms of IIC after this ghastly terror attack. But no. They went ahead and had their usual bonhomie. When I spotted this motley Group including the diplomat turned politician at IIC going back after the talks, I was disgusted and angry. Not for them the value of a soldier's life or the integrity of the country. For them the show must go on. Kashmir conflict suits them so does the sour Indo-Pak relations. If these are over their business and hobby will take a hit and there will be no more talks on which Kasuri the regular guest will Preside. Maybe they will create some other problem to keep themselves busy .
Aarti Khosla
Thursday, 14 December 2017
Forum

Debate: Next Government — 14 Dec 2017

DEBATE (1) Next Government
The fate of Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), led by Narendra Modi that it comes to power in 2019 Lok Sabha Elections for second term or not, will only be decided with the outcome of Gujarat Assembly Elections. The results of Gujarat will pave the way for new political scenario. The outcome will be seen as a litmus test of NDA Government after its detrimental policies. Let’s see whether the politics of fear is the politics of control.
R C Jain
Wednesday, 13 December 2017
Forum

Debate: Next Government — 13 Dec 2017

DEBATE (1) Next Government
The Congress is still labouring under dynastic rule with the result –leaders who can deliver and change the scene are pushed to the wall,
Deepa
DEBATE (2) Next Government
In case there is a fair election, Congress will form the next government.
D P Singh
“Oonchey Log, Neechi Harkat”
The quality of Indian politics has, of late, gone down abysmally low. Sample some dastardly utterances by arrogant politicos Sonia labels Modi : Maut ka saudagar . Priyanka Gandhi blames him for : Khoon ki dalaali . Rahul calls him : “ Gangoo teli, gandi naali ka keera “. All in the family.A small-time politician and a Ra Ga's stooge Sandeep Dikshit labels Army Chief General Rawat : " Sarak kaa goonda " Mani Shankar Aiyar broke all records by blabbering :" Yeh Modi bahut neech kism kaa aadmi hai. Koi sabhyataa nahi hai". The haughty Aiyar , on Dec 7 , 2017,called PM Modi : "Chaiwala in 2014, Neech aadmi in 2017 He takes pride in claiming : " Rahul Gandhi as a Janeu-dhari Brahmin ". The same knucklehead had sought Pakistan's help in removing Modi sarkar. Such elite loose cannons of the dynastic Congress are downright vulgar, uncouth, uncivil and casteist. All at the behest of the dirty-tricks department of the Congress (Rahul ).
PM Modi is OBC. He is dubbed by Aiyar as " Neech " . Do the congis regard SCs and STs as " Maha- Neech". A hideously degenerate mindset. The ,superannuated congis remain moot spectators, vying for photo-ops with the dynasty. Spineless parasites, paid charlatans . Pliant, malleable nincompoops. Aiyar's suspension is no solution. Public demands his immediate expulsion from the party. Even, prosecution under the law of the land for making derogatory references against a particular section of society. Let us wait for peoples' verdicts in HP and Gujarat polls. Who knows, the Congress (Rahul) may emerge as a hypertensive, cardiacally - paralysed party, lodged in ICU, heading towards ventilator.
A K Saxena (A retd civil servant)