Whispers Forum — 13 Oct 2020
DEBATE (1)
IAS officers are visionary. They know their subject very well. How can an IFS see the subject of public interest ?
I D Khatri
Politics of thriving on the crime must stop
I sincerely follow Saxena's messages and find it very crisp and to the point but differ in the context of present Hathras case. Isn’t he also greatly influenced by the 'verdict' already delivered by few channels ? Going by today's report, it appears a failed affair going horribly wrong. Some tinge of old enmities also surfaced. Shouldn't one wait before using such narratives against the crime one has not committed at all. Seeing present scenario, it is falling in 85% category in which Victim and the criminal is known to each other. Though I'm not expert on such matters, I feel it is very difficult to prevent crime against women in such case because known person is least expected to commit crime, though it being done rampantly. Crime should be treated as crime without giving a grading like heinous, more heinous, less heinous etc on the basis of its caste, creed, religion or whether committed in the state ruled by the opposition. Politics of thriving on the crime must stop. We must also find a way to stop the tendency of some group of taking it to international level or UN because they don't like the face of people selected with majority. USA or UK or most advanced countries are no better than India in terms of crime against women.
V K Pandey
A secretary : 1000 watt bulb
Humorous but real.
R K Upadhyay
IAS officers are visionary. They know their subject very well. How can an IFS see the subject of public interest ?
I D Khatri
Politics of thriving on the crime must stop
I sincerely follow Saxena's messages and find it very crisp and to the point but differ in the context of present Hathras case. Isn’t he also greatly influenced by the 'verdict' already delivered by few channels ? Going by today's report, it appears a failed affair going horribly wrong. Some tinge of old enmities also surfaced. Shouldn't one wait before using such narratives against the crime one has not committed at all. Seeing present scenario, it is falling in 85% category in which Victim and the criminal is known to each other. Though I'm not expert on such matters, I feel it is very difficult to prevent crime against women in such case because known person is least expected to commit crime, though it being done rampantly. Crime should be treated as crime without giving a grading like heinous, more heinous, less heinous etc on the basis of its caste, creed, religion or whether committed in the state ruled by the opposition. Politics of thriving on the crime must stop. We must also find a way to stop the tendency of some group of taking it to international level or UN because they don't like the face of people selected with majority. USA or UK or most advanced countries are no better than India in terms of crime against women.
V K Pandey
A secretary : 1000 watt bulb
Humorous but real.
R K Upadhyay