USA still super power country
DEBATE (1)
United States of America (USA) will always be super power country in the world as far as amassing arms and ammunition and army are concerned. Besides, it has strong support of NATO.
Sachin Shrivastava
RTI Act is not a total casualty COVID-19
It is good to see that the RTI Act is not a total casualty of the CoronoVirus infection and the Central Information Commission is atleast giving a semblance of working. The direction for the disclosure of the normalisation process is not legally tenable when the Courts have already said in the case of UPSC that the normalisation process is not to be disclosed. Some of the decisions of the Information Commission are difficult to understand as they seem to be contradictory or appear to be against the judicial verdicts on similar issues. May be, the lockdown would give them time to think about such issues.
Shailendra Sinha
"Out-of-box suggestions by ITOs are not a Misconduct"
Apropos of the post “What to do with ITOs”, published in WIC dt May 11? The author seems biased and intent motivated.
The bureaucracy is free to submit suggestions to cadre-controlling authorities for improving governance and services delivery mechanism. For promoting out-of-box thinking ,bureaucrats based on hands-on experience, are encouraged to make suggestions for consideration of the authorities concerned.
In the context of extant circulars , a body of 50 IRS officers devoid of malicious intent, took pride in making some suggestions for reviving the Indian economy by levying 40% tax on super-rich companies and surcharge on MNCs. Sending a joint memorandum to CBDT chief for raising revenue to fight Covid-19 infection, was not a crime. Needless to mention that government decision had political overtones ( Read as pressures of top business honchos under garb of Covid -19 crisis) for making out-of-box suggestions in public interest. We are slowly but surely ,moving away from Socialist to Capitalist economy.
Tax officers’ suggestions, though politically incorrect, were worth consideration by the authorities concerned. The decision makers possibly felt piqued and slighted. Taking policy decisions, is the sole prerogative of the political Executive, who possibly felt piqued and slighted. Bureaucrats are considered “excellent subordinates but “ bad advisors.”
Initiating disciplinary proceedings against 50 IT officers for " violating the Conduct Rules", would tantamount to travesty of justice. This cannot stand the scrutiny in the court of law. Besides being demoralizing to officers, this will create an unsavoury controversy for the Govt of India.
PM should intervene.
A K Saxena (A former civil servant)
United States of America (USA) will always be super power country in the world as far as amassing arms and ammunition and army are concerned. Besides, it has strong support of NATO.
Sachin Shrivastava
RTI Act is not a total casualty COVID-19
It is good to see that the RTI Act is not a total casualty of the CoronoVirus infection and the Central Information Commission is atleast giving a semblance of working. The direction for the disclosure of the normalisation process is not legally tenable when the Courts have already said in the case of UPSC that the normalisation process is not to be disclosed. Some of the decisions of the Information Commission are difficult to understand as they seem to be contradictory or appear to be against the judicial verdicts on similar issues. May be, the lockdown would give them time to think about such issues.
Shailendra Sinha
"Out-of-box suggestions by ITOs are not a Misconduct"
Apropos of the post “What to do with ITOs”, published in WIC dt May 11? The author seems biased and intent motivated.
The bureaucracy is free to submit suggestions to cadre-controlling authorities for improving governance and services delivery mechanism. For promoting out-of-box thinking ,bureaucrats based on hands-on experience, are encouraged to make suggestions for consideration of the authorities concerned.
In the context of extant circulars , a body of 50 IRS officers devoid of malicious intent, took pride in making some suggestions for reviving the Indian economy by levying 40% tax on super-rich companies and surcharge on MNCs. Sending a joint memorandum to CBDT chief for raising revenue to fight Covid-19 infection, was not a crime. Needless to mention that government decision had political overtones ( Read as pressures of top business honchos under garb of Covid -19 crisis) for making out-of-box suggestions in public interest. We are slowly but surely ,moving away from Socialist to Capitalist economy.
Tax officers’ suggestions, though politically incorrect, were worth consideration by the authorities concerned. The decision makers possibly felt piqued and slighted. Taking policy decisions, is the sole prerogative of the political Executive, who possibly felt piqued and slighted. Bureaucrats are considered “excellent subordinates but “ bad advisors.”
Initiating disciplinary proceedings against 50 IT officers for " violating the Conduct Rules", would tantamount to travesty of justice. This cannot stand the scrutiny in the court of law. Besides being demoralizing to officers, this will create an unsavoury controversy for the Govt of India.
PM should intervene.
A K Saxena (A former civil servant)