Tuesday, November 17, 2026
Live
“
“
Voices from the corridors

Whispers Forum

Debates, reader views and sharp takes on the issues shaping governance — a new conversation every week, archived by date.

0 posts 0 months Latest: 6 Jan 2020
  Browse by date   All posts2850
  2026205
  2025312
  2024310
  2023309
  2022309
  2021300
  2020312
  2019309
  2018295
  2017189

All conversations 2,850 posts · page 172 of 238

Monday, 6 January 2020

Whispers Forum — 6 Jan 2020

DEBATE(1)
The whole premise that a country as large and diverse as India, having such complex governance issues, can be “run” by one individual is a false idea and narrative that the ruling party wants you to believe. The country is governed by ministers, bureaucrats and technocrats who have respective domain expertise. Unlike now where, rightly or wrongly everything is attributed to one person (or 2 recently).
Konark Bhandari
DEBATE(2)
None other than Amit Shah can be the Prime Minister after Modi
R K Tayal
Empowering women in Budget
There is big aberration in tax treatment among family members. This is simple example and easy to understand. When a person retires from service and he receives pensionary benefits and other retirement benefits, there are family members like son, daughter, wife etc. among whom the retiree distributes his retirement money . There is no problem in case of son, daughter and mother but when he gives money to his wife as a family member her income - on money received from husband - will be clubbed with husband income which is not correct. On the other hand, the income of son, daughter and mother will be treated as his or her income. Similarly, the wife’s income should also be treated as her income not to be clubbed with husband’s income at least in case of retirement money. It is OK as long as the person is in service, the income can be clubbed not on retirement money. Let the wife treat it as her own money and interest or income earned from money received as a share from her husband to be treated her own income not to be clubbed with husband income. Now FM being women may appreciate the issue much better and at least give this much to women on retirement money received from their husband. This looks a fair treatment and should be considered favourably by the FM in coming Budget to empower the women as a independent identity.
Naveen
Deferment of promotions
When Modi became PM all Indians expected that his government would follow the rule of law in letter and spirit and save common people from bureaucratic tyranny. I regret to inform you that right under Modi’s vigil in the PMO, the rules set by the DoPT with regard to promotions are being ignored without any regard for those rules. Further, several Supreme Court orders in this regard are not being followed. In the garb of deferment, promotions are being denied to deserving officers though no charges are pending against them merely because some frivolous complaints are pending against them. This is in gross violation of Supreme Court orders in the cases of UoI v Anil Kumar Sarkar and UoI v K V Janaki Raman. These violations are more rampant in CBDT and CBEC.
By A Visitor
Saturday, 4 January 2020

Whispers Forum — 4 Jan 2020

DEBATE(1)
There is a leadership crisis in the country. There is none other than Narendra Modi.
Raj Kumar
DEBATE(2)
Sharad Pawar and Rahul Gandhi. In BJP only Raj Nath Singh.
S S Aporiya
A welcome step
Thanks for settling the issue with the case law. There was a lot of confusion whether similar or identical applications should be replied to ...... At least now the SPIO/ CPIO would know that he has to respond to each and every application filed under the RTI Act. Similar applications cannot be kept away as the earlier application on the issue was replied to. This would increase the work load in terms of sending the photocopy of the earlier reply, but a certainty in the matter is welcome.
Swami Periyar
Gulping of public money
No body is talking about the gulping of public money by the Senior Bureaucrats and Ministers in the form of excess consumption of fuel/vehicles for personal purposes, hospitality expenses over & above entitlement and misuse of staff/officials (excess employment in their personal establishment) for personal purposes.
BBS
Negativity also pervades society
Lafadaa, Fasaad, Vitandabad Test not the power of the Devil. Negativity also pervades society; perhaps in equal amount in proportion to positivity. Neglect the word and it can cause all varieties of infections in social life of a country. Academic hygiene demands alertness at a level surpassed by the armed forces at the LAC. Social debility is caused by abuse of the word. Something akin to Life Style Diseases pervades conditions which can not be cured and can only be managed by regular medication. According to a study, 3 out of 4 young people suffer from high blood pressure. Another study had predicted diabetes, mental health and other problems. Medication costs a lot and still the patient fails to return to normal health enjoyed before suffering the silent attack from the disease. Social disorder caused by lafadaa, fasaad and vitanda has the same, even worse, effect on peace, harmony, law & order, fraternity, unity and integrity. A matter of thought in these Devil inspired times inverting the word completely !
M L Gupta
Friday, 3 January 2020

Whispers Forum — 3 Jan 2020

DEBATE (1)
Only well experienced Sharad Pawar.
R Rathee
DEBATE (2)
Raj Nath Singh 2. Amit Shah 3. Devendra Fadvavis (X- factor) 4. N Chandra Babu Naidu (X-Factor)
Vjay Kant Pandey
"Non-news as Breaking news”
Writing TV news script is a lot harder than one might think. Indian TV news script writers never write for ears. Hence, more often than not, these are out of sync with visuals based on ground realities. All TV channels have the inherent propensity to show every news as Breaking News. All under TRP compulsions. In the competition for One-up-manship, news are hyped so much that the script writers, invariably end up making a mockery of themselves and worse, mislead the viewers.
Sample the following "Breaking News" that appeared simultaneously on all TV channels, on Dec 30 ,2019.
First Breaking news :- Priyanka Gandhi is reaching Delhi by road as the flight was cancelled due to fog. Worse, the news was repeated several times in succession.
Second Breaking news :--Fire breaks out in PM House ( PMH) ;
Third Breaking News :-PM Modi promptly consoled all his fans by tweeting " that there was no fire in PMH ( 7 Lok samiti marg) and there was a short circuit in SPG House (9 Lok samiti marg) "
Questions
(a) Whether there are criteria for categorizing the News. Priyanka Gandhi’s travel mode is a non-news ; (b) How did the PM butt in ? Is he a specialist? (c) Where did engineers disappear despite ? Who leaked the news to the Media? ( d) Was attempt was made through the Tweets to attract global attention; ( e) Are there any standard guidelines to regulate media hypes ?
Will the News Broadcasting agency or m/I&B issue appropriate advisories to TV channels to exercise utmost restraint in analyzing the news-worthiness before classifying them as normal or breaking news?
A K Saxena (A former civil servant)
CBIC has done it again
Earlier It has promoted Direct recruit ACs of 2014 on !st Jan 2019 to the post of DC (STS), now it has come out with Office order no,175/2019 where in it has promoted Direct recruit ACs of 2015 batch to the post of DC (STS). Promotion orders from DC (STS) to JC (JAG) have also been issued. All the orders are on ad-hoc basis i.e as per para 5 of the order promotion shall not confer any right on the officers so promoted for any claim for regular promotion in the grade of DC & the period of such service will not count for seniority or as qualifying service for further promotions. CBIC can very well promote the Promotee ACs of 2014 putting in the same condition. The whole batch of Direct Recruit Officers are promoted enmasse and no sanction strength or availability of posts come in the way. Every time promotion orders of Direct recruit ACs are issued few promotee ACs from Appraiser cadre are also promoted. In 2014 order 10 such Promotee ACs (from Appraiser cadre) were promoted and in order issued on 30/12/2019, 20 Promotee ACs from Appraiser cadre have been promoted to the post of DC. Why no Promotee AC from the cadre of Superintendents (who are much senior to Appraisers in feeder cadre) have been promoted to the rank of DC. The conduct of CBIC is not above the board. There surely a promotion mafia operating in the Board which must be investigated by CBI.
Durgesh Makwana
Childish claim
CBIC promoted ACs in 2014 not on charity. It is a childish claim & it appears that writer is not aware of promotion rules at the level of Group A officers. Due permission, approval & concurrence of DOPT UPSC & ACC is taken. Due requirement in wake of upcoming tax reform of century i.e. GST was kept in the mind while promoting them. Department will further be benefited by their rich experience, by promoting them, which will keep them motivated and boost their morale. CBIC must give a serious thought that if they promote 2015 batch of Direct recruit ACs (who have completed only 4 years of service, which include two years of training) to the rank of DCs (STS Scale) on !st Jan 2020, by overlooking promotee ACs of 2014 it will be committing a Himalayan Blunder as CBIC has already promoted Direct Recruit ACs of 2014 batch on !st Jan 2019. Not only will there be spate of court cases, VRSs, but demotivated and demoralised officers, will not be able to give their best, when that are most required, when the GST Revenue is going downhill. For more than 95% of them, it will be the last promotion of their life. The promotion to the next rank of DC in STS will boost their morale to walk an extra mile for the People and Govt of their country. GST has been PMs most important project in Tax Reforms. If PM looks into the matter, injustice being done to the Promotee ACs of 2014 batch who have completed more than 5 years of service in JTS can be set upright, as CBIC is openly biased against them.
Dharmesh Singh
Congratulations !
Congratulation Rajesh Bhushan Sir for being Secretary (RD) Ministry of Rural Development.
Sanjeev Kumar
Thursday, 2 January 2020

Whispers Forum — 2 Jan 2020

DEBATE (1)
In my view Naveen Patnaik followed by Sharad Pawar. Patnaik will make good PM while Pawar with his experience will do well.
Raghu Thakur
DEBATE(2)
None...if any body claims so.. CBI ED raid Tihar jail will be waiting for him.
Venkateswara Rao Dhulipala
Only Modi can ensure justice !
Govt. does not fill Group "A" level posts, for the sake of charity or generosity. Recruitment at Group A level is always done strictly as per requirement of Govt. For filling up the posts of ACs from promotion in 2014, due approval of DOPT, UPSC & ACC was taken by the CBIC. The arrogance & ignorance of Mr. Vikas Singh has been revealed through his write up. Are Supdts. & Appraisers responsible for stagnation, or policies of Govt. ? 9 officers who have joined the Department as Appraisers have been promoted to the rank of Commissioners vide Office Order no 158/2019 dated 29/11/2019 issued by CBIC. Is it a crime to aspire for promotion ? Yes, if CBIC can manage to meet or surpass the targets of CGST collection without their services, revert them! This is not British Rule. This is Modi Government, so choose your words and action carefully. It is requested that PMO must intervene in this matter urgently and Promotee ACs of 2014 should also be promoted to DC in STS pay scale after 4 years of service, before the junior direct recruit ACs of (2015) are promoted to the rank of DC. CBIC has already done grave injustice by promoting direct ACs of 2014 on 1st Jan 2019 to the rank of DC (who have joined the service after Promotee ACs of 2014) and overlooking Promotee ACs of 2014 batch. Only clear cut instructions from Prime Minister Narendra Modi can ensure justice for promotee ACs of 2014 of CBIC.
Vijay Mahadevan
LTCG on transfer of equity shares/equity oriented MF
Till FY 2107-18 LTCG on transfer of equity share and units of equity oriented MF was exempted under section 10(38). Vide Finance Bill 2018, the new section 112A has been inserted in order to levy long-term capital gain tax on the transfer of equity share, units of equity oriented funds and units of the business trust. Further, in order to levy long term capital gain tax @10%, the capital gain should be exceeding INR 1 Lakh. It means there is no tax liability upto 1 lakh. The attention of FM and PM is drawn why un-necessary details are being asked in ITR even if LTCG in such cases is less than 1 lakh or loss. It is understood that notices have been issued for mismatch and it is really a difficult for CPC task to match each and every entry of ITRs knowing well there is no tax liability from assesses side and no revenue to the Govt. Cases can be understood and details are required if LTCG in such cases exceeds 1 lakh. Simply the information can be asked as per Sec112A for reporting purpose as was being followed till FY 2107-18 under Sec 10 (38). Secretary, Revenue is nodal authority and should take up the case with CBDT for simplification of the procedure as it helps both sides. There is wastage of time, manpower and financial resources etc without any revenue. The same resources can be used for some innovative solution of prevailing situations and plugging the revenue leakages. It is well known that a small mistake may invite big problem and may be the first step towards harassment of tax payers. To avoid such situations and problems let us follow the simple solution of the problem. We can still workout better method to increase revenue by withdrawing LTCG tax i instead increase STT which is simpler way of collecting taxes. Whenever there is a transaction STT is calculated and deposited by the stock exchanges in Govt, accounts on settlement. Each and every transaction gives the revenue to the Govt. without involving tax payers and tax authorities. No complexity in filing ITRs and wastage of resources by the Govt. and still there is increase in revenue. These are simpler way of boosting the revenues and sentiments of the investors. This will make the tax payers life simpler specially salaried class, sr. citizens, pensioners who mostly files ITR1. The tax compliance is highest in this category and we should make their life simple not complex. Let us hope for good solution.
Naveen
Excellent move by GoI
John Joseph -Excellent move by GOI. Due has been given to bold and dynamic officer.
Sanjeev Kabbur
Wednesday, 1 January 2020

1 Raj Nath Singh

DEBATE (1)
2 Shiv Raj Singh
3 Priyanka Gandhi
Dinesh Gupta
DEBATE (2)
Mamta Banerjee and Amrinder Singh
A Joshi
People voted smartly in 2019
The people of India have voted smartly in 2019. For PM and Central Govt, they wanted BJP & leadership of PM MODI. It will be the same in 2024. For State Governments they want focus on local issues. In Maharashtra & Haryana the local people wanted NDA Alliance. SS betrayal of alliance will be punished. The weakness of state level CM's in BJP is evident . Hence the loss of power. In Jharkhand the tribal population punished BJP CM for his anti - tribal stance ! He lost 28 sure shot seats there. This must not be repeated in 2020 . Currently there is no opposition leader who can compete with PM Modi.
Devindra
Railway restructuring without analysing working requirements
True. The Railway work force is not only immense but highly diversified work-wise---from gangmen checking the tracks daily to mechanics /fitters in workshops / loco or carriage and wagon sheds to signalmen to commercial booking clerks to accountants to storekeepers,........the categories, pay-structures/promotional avenues/recruitments etc. are way too many. Also, the all important industrial relations--UNIONS to work with. Therefore the Personnel service at field/zonal levels and a Member Staff in the Rly. Bd. The restructuring has been done without going deep into the working requirements of the largest employer in the World.
V Nanda
Tuesday, 31 December 2019

Whispers Forum — 31 Dec 2019

DEBATE(1)
If you want to see another Indira Gandhi then Priyanka Gandhi will make an effective PM.
Ruchi Garg
(DEBATE)
1. Priyanka Gandhi
2. Mamta Banerjee
3. Arvind Kejriwal
Amit Pande
Do not engage in wild speculations !
What should we infer when you say that 2024 will be the last general elections for BJP. You are saying by this statement that BJP will wind up. What you probably wanted to say is that they will lose power because of the recent trends. A result in Jharkand is purely on local issues and it does not reflect national opinion. Similarly in Maharashtra, BJP should have been in power but for the hunger of a power of a particular party which resulted in all political decency and scruples thrown to the winds. So your argument is based on talks between anti BJP people like JNU, Jamia, AMU, Lutyens Delhi who are all a minuscule of the country's electorate. Please do not start your guess work based upon opinion from such elements. The overwhelming approval is for BJP and PM and they will thump all other parties and come to power. Yes setbacks will be there, all the misrule of past so many years has to be overcome for results to show, so do not engage in wild speculations please in December 2019 when the next elections are only in May 2024.
K Srinivasa R
Condition of Insurance Sector may match with others
If the present scenario goes on, condition of Insurance Sector will be like Real Estate Sector, Aviation Sector, Banking Sector etc.
RajeshTenany.
Monday, 30 December 2019

In serial order:

DEBATE (1)
1. Mrs. Sonia Gandhi
2. Sharad Pawar
3. Kamal Nath
Paarth Garg
DEBATE (2)
Yogi Adityanath, C M, U. P. 2) Amit Shaw 3) Rajanath Singh.
Suryanarayana Murty Kolluri
“Garnering votes by throwing tax payers’ money down the drain?”
In the run upto Assembly election in Delhi in Feb,2020, there is a tough competition going on between Modi sarkar and the present AAP sarkar in wooing voters in Delhi. Result : Wasteful spending from public funds on advertisements, rallies, free power ,free rides for ladies in DTC .Other freebies and still counting . C&AG and CEC are clueless, helpless. At least , so it seems. The buck does not stop here. The public is gullible and the Media unmindful.
Consider another illegality.
Saturday, 28 December 2019

Whispers Forum — 28 Dec 2019

DEBATE (1)
With all his experience, only Sharad Pawar will make a good PM.
A C Gulati
Fake News Old Business, Satyagrah - it’s only Anti-dote
Fake news suddenly has become “The News” these days. The only difference now is the speed with which it spreads in no time. In the earlier format the people had to wait for the newspaper next day, but technology has given the power to every individual to be his or her newspaper, journalist, editor and publisher. With liberal ideas about freedom of speech and expression, reasonable restrictions are not exercised. Instead any demand for restraint or restriction by the law is strongly resented. So, a huge ready market for it yields instant dividends. Fake news, disinformation and misinformation are subjects of many best selling international titles. The “intelligence agencies” are realising the dangers of fake news as misuse of the internet, FB, Twitter, WhatsApp etc. is creating law & order problems. Aren’t the newspapers and TV channels inflaming public sentiments by creative headlines, anchor stories and photographs? People believe the media. Hence, it becomes its duty to remain truthful in all circumstances.
M L Gupta
Friday, 27 December 2019

Whispers Forum — 27 Dec 2019

DEBATE (1)
In my view, after Narendra Modi, Arvind Kejriwal, Nitish Kumar and Mamta Banerjee fall in this category.
Badal Garg
Treatment of LTCG in forthcoming Budget
The budget preparation is on and discussions are taking place at all levels. It looks very surprising neither finance ministry nor CBDT is worried about removal of LTCG on transfer of equity and equity oriented MF to boost market sentiments and increase consumption. There is no doubt economy is moving downwards and speed breakers like LTCG will create further problems and may result in crashing of stock market if irritants are not removed in the budget. It looks very surprising that income tax authorities are asking to fill up the details as per ITR 2 in case there is loss or LTCG is less than 1 lakh knowing well there is no tax liability. This is something unexplained even why such details are being asked in ITR. It gives rise to suspescion and may lead to harassment of tax payers in case of some mismatch. When we are moving to faceless scrutiny and pre-filled ITR regime why enter into complexity of asking the details without any tax obligations. If logic is further extended then nearly 35 crores people are required to file the ITRs to know that is there any tax liability on the income or not. Simply ask the information for reporting purpose as was being followed till FY 2017-18. Let the department to focus how to judge the correctness of income of professionals instead of asking un-necessary details on LTCG. There is no tools or methodologies available with tax officials to judge the correctness of income and tax obligations on professionals. There is differential treatment also in case of professionals and salaried class. Giving 50% rebate upto 5o lakhs income is no good idea to justify that there is expenditure on account of maintenance of office and staff etc. whereas in salaried class there is no such expenditure so no concessions. This is not logical. The standard deduction in case of salaried class is to be increased to bring at par with professionals for tax treatment. Excess flow of cash is also not good for economy in the country. This excess cash runs parallel economy and can be seen how big cash is being seized in raids. Govt. should consider no cash transaction of more than Rs. 10,000/-. Let it be digital or thru plastic cards as 90% people estimated are having bank accounts and Aadhar and they can be provided the facilities of any media for transactions. Govt. should consider removal of LTCG in case of equity transfer or equity oriented MF and may consider of increasing STT if necessary. Such policy oriented approach may increase the confidence of investors and will result in increase in investment and boost the sentiments which is very much required at this juncture to lift the overall economy. The mechanical approach like reducing repo rate will not boost the economic growth keeping in mind RBI to concentrate on Monetary Policies to maintain the price stability and control the inflation etc and Ministry on growth.
Naveen
Govt. attention required
These Assistant Commissioners were promoted on the basis of charity, to avoid stagnation, and 4000 posts were created for them on temporary basis. The same is being extended by CBIC as a goodwill gesture. Now, the same people, who have been shown generosity by the CBIC, are demanding for further promotion, knowing well that the ratio, as decided for the promotion posts as well as direct recruits, does not allow it. Are these promoted Assistant Commissioners, of 2014, as stated, willing for reversion to their earlier posts of Superintendents or Appraisers? If so, the government should think over it and revert them back, by abolishing 4000 posts created temporarily for them.
Vikas Singh
Why do always the most incapable get plum postings? Even post retirement?
Ashok Menon
Thursday, 26 December 2019

Whispers Forum — 26 Dec 2019

DEBATE (1)
Except Narendra Modi none because everyone thinks that country is in safe hands and corruption at the centre is negligible as compared to states.
L S Hardenia
DEBATE (2)
Except Narendra Modi no one is PM material in the country.
N Rawat
Nothing wrong
There is absolutely nothing wrong in mentioning coincidence of all the top three in MoF are from particular state Caste. It’s excellent journalism. Not at all offensive. Thanks for the information.
NVN
Thank you so much
Thank you so much for taking up the matter of promotion of Promotee ACs of 2014 (promoted on 22/10/2014) of CBIC. CBIC promoted them since there was requirement of Officers at the level of ACs, but now do not want to contaminate its blue blood under the bureaucratic jargon of adhoc, temporary. Records can be seen CBIC has been promoting officers on adhoc basis till the rank of Commissioners. How come vacancies for Direct Recruit ACs in subsequent years, in 2014,2015,2016,2017,2018 came out to be regular vacancies and vacancies for Promotee ACs who were promoted on 22/10/2014 and joined before Direct ACs of 2014, have been termed adhoc temporary. If you don't require services of Promotee ACs revert them, but don't humiliate them. As such in past PAC of Parliament has already indicted CBIC as "habitual litigant." It does not act without court orders. This Promotion Scam needs to be seriously investigated.
Dinesh
Wednesday, 25 December 2019

Putin doesn't stand a chance

About the global leader as of now, Putin doesn't stand a chance it has to USA, China or India..so if not Modi then Xi should be world leader though he is not in best of his times.
Kundan Lal
Happenings in the country quite worrisome
What is happening in the country is quite worrisome. First Assam erupted against NRC followed by other North-East states. After the passage of Citizenship Amendment Bill now almost the entire country is burning including the Capital .The brutal treatment of Jamia students by police where many students have been left with injuries, fractures and one with damaged eye is really condemnable. This has provoked students from other educational institutions to come out in support of these students and against the CAA and NRC. Some mischievous and anti-social elements seem to have infiltrated these protesters and indulged in rioting destroying buses and attacking police. Instead of assuaging the young students and reprimanding the police for entering the campus at Jamia as also in AMU they were encouraged to go ahead with harsh action against the students. Looking at what is happening one wonders whether we are a democratic country since the dissent is met with baton beating teargas shells and even detention and arrest. Democracy does not mean that we have election after five years and once voted the Government can do anything without consulting public opinion or we follow an agenda contrary to what people want and there is absolute opaqueness (as in the project for Central Vista development) where huge amount of public expenditure is involved people have the right to know and speak.
Aarti Khosla
Tuesday, 24 December 2019

CBIC discriminating

CBIC discriminating between Promotee ACs of 2014 & Direct ACs of 2014 & 2015. Direct ACs of 2014 have been promoted on 01/01/2019 & DPC for Direct ACs of 2015 has been done & order expected on 01/01/2020, again Promotee ACs of 2014 have been left out. Are Promotee ACs untouchables or only blue blood runs in the veins of CBIC ??? Revert them if you don’t require their services but don’t humiliate them by asking them to work under juniors. Gross violation of constitution !
Pradeep