Whispers Forum — 6 Jan 2020
DEBATE(1)
The whole premise that a country as large and diverse as India, having such complex governance issues, can be “run” by one individual is a false idea and narrative that the ruling party wants you to believe. The country is governed by ministers, bureaucrats and technocrats who have respective domain expertise. Unlike now where, rightly or wrongly everything is attributed to one person (or 2 recently).
Konark Bhandari
DEBATE(2)
None other than Amit Shah can be the Prime Minister after Modi
R K Tayal
Empowering women in Budget
There is big aberration in tax treatment among family members. This is simple example and easy to understand. When a person retires from service and he receives pensionary benefits and other retirement benefits, there are family members like son, daughter, wife etc. among whom the retiree distributes his retirement money . There is no problem in case of son, daughter and mother but when he gives money to his wife as a family member her income - on money received from husband - will be clubbed with husband income which is not correct. On the other hand, the income of son, daughter and mother will be treated as his or her income. Similarly, the wife’s income should also be treated as her income not to be clubbed with husband’s income at least in case of retirement money. It is OK as long as the person is in service, the income can be clubbed not on retirement money. Let the wife treat it as her own money and interest or income earned from money received as a share from her husband to be treated her own income not to be clubbed with husband income. Now FM being women may appreciate the issue much better and at least give this much to women on retirement money received from their husband. This looks a fair treatment and should be considered favourably by the FM in coming Budget to empower the women as a independent identity.
Naveen
Deferment of promotions
When Modi became PM all Indians expected that his government would follow the rule of law in letter and spirit and save common people from bureaucratic tyranny. I regret to inform you that right under Modi’s vigil in the PMO, the rules set by the DoPT with regard to promotions are being ignored without any regard for those rules. Further, several Supreme Court orders in this regard are not being followed. In the garb of deferment, promotions are being denied to deserving officers though no charges are pending against them merely because some frivolous complaints are pending against them. This is in gross violation of Supreme Court orders in the cases of UoI v Anil Kumar Sarkar and UoI v K V Janaki Raman. These violations are more rampant in CBDT and CBEC.
By A Visitor
The whole premise that a country as large and diverse as India, having such complex governance issues, can be “run” by one individual is a false idea and narrative that the ruling party wants you to believe. The country is governed by ministers, bureaucrats and technocrats who have respective domain expertise. Unlike now where, rightly or wrongly everything is attributed to one person (or 2 recently).
Konark Bhandari
DEBATE(2)
None other than Amit Shah can be the Prime Minister after Modi
R K Tayal
Empowering women in Budget
There is big aberration in tax treatment among family members. This is simple example and easy to understand. When a person retires from service and he receives pensionary benefits and other retirement benefits, there are family members like son, daughter, wife etc. among whom the retiree distributes his retirement money . There is no problem in case of son, daughter and mother but when he gives money to his wife as a family member her income - on money received from husband - will be clubbed with husband income which is not correct. On the other hand, the income of son, daughter and mother will be treated as his or her income. Similarly, the wife’s income should also be treated as her income not to be clubbed with husband’s income at least in case of retirement money. It is OK as long as the person is in service, the income can be clubbed not on retirement money. Let the wife treat it as her own money and interest or income earned from money received as a share from her husband to be treated her own income not to be clubbed with husband income. Now FM being women may appreciate the issue much better and at least give this much to women on retirement money received from their husband. This looks a fair treatment and should be considered favourably by the FM in coming Budget to empower the women as a independent identity.
Naveen
Deferment of promotions
When Modi became PM all Indians expected that his government would follow the rule of law in letter and spirit and save common people from bureaucratic tyranny. I regret to inform you that right under Modi’s vigil in the PMO, the rules set by the DoPT with regard to promotions are being ignored without any regard for those rules. Further, several Supreme Court orders in this regard are not being followed. In the garb of deferment, promotions are being denied to deserving officers though no charges are pending against them merely because some frivolous complaints are pending against them. This is in gross violation of Supreme Court orders in the cases of UoI v Anil Kumar Sarkar and UoI v K V Janaki Raman. These violations are more rampant in CBDT and CBEC.
By A Visitor