Conviction of Gupta former Secretary Coal
DEBATE (1)
Only Gupta and his party need to be blamed firstly for the motivated mess the bureaucracy created to dole out the largesse worth millions and billions of exchequers money through illegal allotment of coal blocks to their favourites and secondly when caught by the long arms of law , a rare of the rarest phenomena in and for IAS lobby as the system created by and for them have no holes for their scrutiny except the intervention of courts as in the instant case, accusing the former Prime Minister who was holding the charge of this Ministry on the pretext of giving/receiving oral directions in a particular manner ultimately leading to the massive scam. Secretary or Joint Secretaries are not so fools that they shall comply with the illegal or corrupt oral instructions of the Minister in a manner of dancing. In fact it is the other way round that the Politician is misguided by a corrupt IAS officer through his articulation on file in such a convincing manner that the no scope is left for the Minister to invoke his wisdom except to append his approval assuming the recommendations as gospel truth. Gupta, sincere if he was had enormous scope , opportunity and authority to preempt any illegal oral orders of the Coal Minister if at all they were whispered by systematically questioning the merits of such efforts on file . Assuming hypothetically that a corrupt politician would want his writ and not the merits, policy and procedure to prevail on file only a corrupt bureaucrat interested in collecting extra booty would fall in line. There are hundreds of instances wherein a bureaucrat defied the wrong instructions of the powerful ministers with humility without caring for the consequences. However a corrupt may initiate or fall in line for ulterior gains would always blame the master for his own misdeeds. The Presiding Officer of this special Court that convicted Gupta is a living example of honesty and integrity that are rated above board. He is known for blindfolding his eyes while determining the guilt on the basis of presentation of facts both by prosecution as well as accused and takes no time in granting acquittal if the justice demands so. The court would never be pleased to send the accused to jail without establishing his guilt through corroborating evidence. The Court, in the instant case has rather been lenient in punishing the convict with two years of jail term as against the maximum of seven that he and his supporters must acknowledge and be gracious to the Court.
O P Sharma
Many officers retired in wait of promotion
Hundreds of the eligible Under Secretaries, who have completed more than the required five years of regular service, are stagnating at the US level, even though the vacancies at DS level are available. Many of those have retired in wait of promotion. So frustrating....
Purnendu Kant
No promotion is being made in CSSS posts as well, i.e. PA, PS, PPS, SrPPS & PSO.
Satish
Only Gupta and his party need to be blamed firstly for the motivated mess the bureaucracy created to dole out the largesse worth millions and billions of exchequers money through illegal allotment of coal blocks to their favourites and secondly when caught by the long arms of law , a rare of the rarest phenomena in and for IAS lobby as the system created by and for them have no holes for their scrutiny except the intervention of courts as in the instant case, accusing the former Prime Minister who was holding the charge of this Ministry on the pretext of giving/receiving oral directions in a particular manner ultimately leading to the massive scam. Secretary or Joint Secretaries are not so fools that they shall comply with the illegal or corrupt oral instructions of the Minister in a manner of dancing. In fact it is the other way round that the Politician is misguided by a corrupt IAS officer through his articulation on file in such a convincing manner that the no scope is left for the Minister to invoke his wisdom except to append his approval assuming the recommendations as gospel truth. Gupta, sincere if he was had enormous scope , opportunity and authority to preempt any illegal oral orders of the Coal Minister if at all they were whispered by systematically questioning the merits of such efforts on file . Assuming hypothetically that a corrupt politician would want his writ and not the merits, policy and procedure to prevail on file only a corrupt bureaucrat interested in collecting extra booty would fall in line. There are hundreds of instances wherein a bureaucrat defied the wrong instructions of the powerful ministers with humility without caring for the consequences. However a corrupt may initiate or fall in line for ulterior gains would always blame the master for his own misdeeds. The Presiding Officer of this special Court that convicted Gupta is a living example of honesty and integrity that are rated above board. He is known for blindfolding his eyes while determining the guilt on the basis of presentation of facts both by prosecution as well as accused and takes no time in granting acquittal if the justice demands so. The court would never be pleased to send the accused to jail without establishing his guilt through corroborating evidence. The Court, in the instant case has rather been lenient in punishing the convict with two years of jail term as against the maximum of seven that he and his supporters must acknowledge and be gracious to the Court.
O P Sharma
Many officers retired in wait of promotion
Hundreds of the eligible Under Secretaries, who have completed more than the required five years of regular service, are stagnating at the US level, even though the vacancies at DS level are available. Many of those have retired in wait of promotion. So frustrating....
Purnendu Kant
No promotion is being made in CSSS posts as well, i.e. PA, PS, PPS, SrPPS & PSO.
Satish